No, he wasn't. Most felt like he was too young to win a fight like that and he simply didn't have the quickness and speed to hang with Floyd."… Canelo Alvarez isn’t the best fighter in boxing, but there are few guys I want to watch more when they enter the ring. His destruction of James Kirkland might be boxing’s signature moment of the year thus far."
Yet Mayweather beat Canelo as well. Canelo was supposed to knock Floyd out.
12-round decision for Floyd was always going to be the result when they fought when they fought.