ADVERTISEMENT

Ketch's 10 Thoughts From The Weekend (Imagine if Hudson Card had been ranked correctly...)

All from a few people on a staff that got fired & by all accounts didn’t put the program in the best position to be successful. So I dang sure wouldn’t use that as my main point of rebuttal. & I could throw out a few quotes from that same previous staff that stated Thompson out performed Sam for a spring but never saw you blowing up The internet with that. I respect you as a guy who has been around doing the message board thing but your slip is showing on this one for sure. & by the way, you do realize that there are some that say Hudson was only shown a lot of grace with his ranking due to the history of his school Qb legacy & not through his actual on field performance & lack of longevity at playing Qb in HS. You do know there are some Texas high school coaches who played against him that think very opposite of what you do. But everyone has an opinion & entitled to one.
The last staff didn’t play our best players so of course they liked Casey over Hudson.
 
Ketch...Great write-up...I sure hope you are correct regarding Card as I think all of us do. I wish I had come onboard far earlier. It has been a fun year becoming acquainted with OB. You have an excellent fan site.

But in my short time here, I will take issue with you regarding being kind of a pain in the ass...and to illustrate the point with the substitution of a few words...I call Ty Webb as my first witness...keep it up and keep us on our toes...

 
Ketch, I enjoy your writings, but wish you would make better usage of your great vocabulary than to use the slang-curse words. They are negative reflections on your writings and are offensive to this reader. It is like when I go to a PG movie and have to walk out during the action due to the offensive language. I appreciate you for your talent and would have an even greater appreciation when you drop the four letter words. You vocabulary is much better than that.
10-4. I'll keep it in mind.
 
A live game!! Singular, right. I saw Jerrold Heard play in a live game once and in that game he was the best QB in UT history. That too was a singular game. Colorado sucks, let it play out. Oh, how bout that pick six in the spring game, you didn’t bring that up. In my mind, UT will be better by conference play if Card has three games to get used to the speed as opposed to Casey.
I can bring up the pick six because it was bad but go back & watch the Utep game where he score on 2 of his 3 drives. I mean this kid has threw TD’s or lead to scores on 7 or 8 of his live game opportunities & has performed pretty well in both other spring games as well since on the forty. Most of you pumping Card only have 1 or 2 passes in the recent spring game to point to but you all also never bring up his bad plays & bounce passes & his misreads but the minute he throws a 6 yd TD pass. All of you have him as a Heisman candidate & 1st round selection. Obviously I’m just not a member of the good ole boy club & seems like Thompson can’t win either way with this crew! No wonder we have struggled with a top notch Qb to get us back where we belong. Some of you need to just keep your day job & leave coaching to those that know how to truly evaluate them. This isn’t a popularity contest amongst the Good ole Boy Club!.🤔🤔
 
The subjectiveness of those conversations is exactly why I use a non-subjective metric of analysis.

I don’t think it’s subjective analysis to say Bomar, Shep and Gilbert grossly underperformed in college relative to the rankings as QBs out of HS.
 
  • Like
Reactions: magnahorn
Here’s a better Manchester band I bet you need a deep dive in to also: The Stone Roses. I love Oasis but SR have a much deeper catalogue and much more unique sound. Give them a listen. Start with the song “Love Spreads”.
 
Normally I’d say that’s some tin foil hat stuff going on with your QB reps in the spring game stuff, but Sark has to try to keep both somehow and he was never going to outright name a starter until he had to. I still don’t know if you can sacrifice reps for a guy that needs them and you clearly think can be special with reps just for the sake of appearances. I agree that he can’t name a starter until game week for several reasons.
 
ee0e3a40b744e2eebc3b4d949eaa9055x.jpg

Twenty-two years ago, the top quarterback recruit in the country rolled into Austin with the wildest recruiting buzz in the history of this town.

Ricky Williams had just won the Heisman, and Mack Brown's arsenal as a recruiter was just starting to be fully weaponized with the arrival of Chris Simms.

You Applewhite cultists might have heard of him.

It's hard to quantify the buzz that Simms brought. Some folks would have you believe that this was pre-Internet, but the truth is it was the Internet that gave birth to his legend. He was the golden boy, and an actual subject of an NFL Films documentary back when that felt like a really big deal. A one-time Tennessee commitment, it was the Internet that kept the dream alive with whispers of hope.

And then it happened. He flipped to Texas, and it felt like the entire burnt orange world changed. Texas mattered again. Simms WAS going to win a national title for the Longhorns... period. Full stop. That was the bar.

That the man showed up (by accident) in a damn limo only added to his hype before he'd ever played in a game.

Poor Major Applewhite. All he'd ever done since entering the starting line-up back in 1998 (with Williams in the backfield) was win games. The dude won in Lincoln, beat Oklahoma and won the Cotton Bowl as a redshirt freshman, and it didn't really matter. The sense was that he was only a place-holder for the really great quarterback that had arrived from New Jersey. It didn't matter that it wasn't all that fair.

CHRIS. MOTHER****ING. SIMMS. Y'ALL.

In the history of modern recruiting rankings (the dawn of Rivals.com in 1999), UT has signed three five-star quarterbacks. Simms in 1999. Vince Young in 2002. Garrett Gilbert in 2009.

Each arrived with a tsunami of hype in this town. Each has his own unique story.

In the quarter-century of recruiting classes that I've been a part of since my initial set of personal rankings in 1997, there's only one other quarterback that Texas has signed that I gave a five-star grade... current redshirt freshman Hudson Card.

I had the kid as a five-star talent from the very first moment I laid eyes on him. There was just no doubt about it in my mind. That kid's arm talent was and continues to be different. Throughout the entire recruiting process, I looked at every recruiting service like it had a damn third eyeball.

Rivals ranked him at 108 overall nationally. 247 ranked him at No. 70 overall. ESPN ranked him at No. 40. Frankly, I thought they were all bat-shit crazy in the wrong way for not being able to see what seemed clear to me when the kid signed with the Longhorns.

Of course, as I write this, fate hasn't yet decided which side of this discussion is actually the batshit crazy side, but as we prepare for an off-season decision that will potentially define the way the Steve Sarkisian Era is ultimately remembered, I want you to do two things.

First read these two quotes.

“I love the guy. Love his accuracy. Hudson can really drive the football. His footwork and ability to throw from any platform. He’s a very intelligent kid. I think Aaron Rodgers is the most talented quarterback ever in terms of skill set. This kid reminds me a lot of Aaron Rodgers in how he can move within the pocket and throw from different arm angles and make off-platform throws, and he’s got really good agility. He’s like a 4.5 (40) guy. I’m not bullshitting you. He’s really that talented.”

"Hudson is just a special player. There's really no other way to put it. He came out of the womb spinning the football. I know that's not the only thing he can do. Obviously, played receiver as a sophomore and got scholarship offers as an athlete at receiver. That's a testament to his athletic ability as well. You watch Hudson throw the ball and you're like, man. There were often times during our practice I was watching him throw like, gosh darn it, why can't I do that? Why can't I spin the way that he can? "

For reference points, the first quote was provided by a former Texas assistant coach in a February piece for The Athletic, while the second came from none other than Sam Ehlinger a few months ago.

The second thing that I'm going to ask of you is to do that thing that Matthew McConaughey did to the jury in A Time to Kill.

I want to tell you a story. I'm gonna ask y'all to close your eyes while I tell you this story. I want you to listen to me. I want you to listen to yourselves.

This is a story about a little quarterback from Austin preparing for a job battle one blazing summer.

Everyone has an opinion about it. Two men argue on Orangebloods about it and threaten each other. They threaten to Wachovia each other if each isn't careful. One of them is from Austin and claims that this is the most talented quarterback to ever come out of this area. His arm has people making Aaron Rodgers references, which sounds about as wild as someone comparing a mere mortal to Vince Young in the open field.

Can you see him? The kid is so good that former coaches dismissed Casey Thompson's performance in the Alamo Bowl, partly because they don't believe he's remotely on the level of the kid from Austin.

Can you see him? I want you to picture that little freshman, the one that a senior that was discussed in Texas quarterback Mount Rushmore terms going into last season gushed over in a way that makes you wonder if he has pictures of him hanging up in his NFL locker room.

Now imagine he's a five-star.

Perhaps the most fascinating component of the quarterback battle that's taking place is the fact that for the first time in my lifetime, I think the collective Texas fanbase doesn't quite know what it has on its hands. He arrived without that shiny ranking next to his name that would have the entire city acting like the UK any time there's a Gallagher brother in the headlines.

The gift that Card has going for him is that he hasn't yet had to deal with the pressure that comes with being a five-star quarterback. Ask Limo. Ask V.Y. Ask Squints.

Five-stars face a pressure sharp enough to cut a diamond, but the only person that really seems to treat Card like a damn five-star is my crazy ass.

All of this madness of the past that I've described would be exactly what this situation would look like if Card had been rated by the national services exactly as I had seen him.

Such an arbitrary thing on paper... these recruiting rankings. I suppose we can argue about the importance of the rankings, but what can't be disputed is the way that they shape public opinion and perceptions. No matter how much praise I lob Card's way, it simply can't influence the Texas fanbase the way five of these can - ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐.

It just didn't go down like that, which is why I often find myself living in a parallel universe to the one inhabited by most of you. In my mind, you guys will eventually come around. The enlightenment will arrive, sooner rather than later.

Unless, I'm just crazy, which will remain a possibility that cannot be discounted.

No. 2 - Speaking of five-stars...

I can't help but wonder if every tight end on the Texas roster didn't waste a chance to put a little distance between themselves and incoming freshman Ja'Tavian Sanders.

Don't get me wrong, I love me some Jared Wiley. I've mentioned that I believe he has NFL upside. Braydon Liebrock is another guy that I think has immense upside. The tight ends on campus have some talent.

Yet, none of these dudes are remotely as freaky as Sanders.

When we talk about the Texas offense in 2021, it's important to note that it's pretty tough to conceptualize what Sanders could possibly add to the offense because, in reality, we've never really seen it around these parts. Once upon a time before he blew out his knee in the state championship game of his senior year, Bo Scaife had this kind of talent.

(Side-note: I wish you guys could have seen Scaife before the knee injury. He would have been special.)

As much as this defense needs all hands on deck with regards to pass-rushing, I just have a hard time believing that Sarkisian is ever going to let Sanders live on the other side of the ball. Hell, maybe it's the reason he's allowed the defense to have almost every single transfer possible.

"Want five linebackers in the portal? Sure, just keep your hands off my five-star," I can imagine Sarkisian saying in his head.

When it's all said and done, the kid that is showing up on campus this week might just be the thing that makes this offense jump the rail in the best way possible and there might not be a single thing that the current Texas tight ends or Pete Kwiatkowski can do about it.

No. 3 - In addition to Sanders...

These are the three freshmen that arrive this week that I believe could have a major impact on the 2021 season.

a. Xavier Worthy - I'm not sure who keeps him off the field. There's not a like for like talent blocking his pathway to playing time.

b. Jordan Thomas - If he can bring pressure off the edge, something he has shown flashes of as a high school player, there's going to be playing time. Maybe a lot of it.

c. David Abiara - I've always been a little higher on the former Notre Dame commitment than most. His size as a true freshman gives him a chance. Like Thomas, if he can display skill off the edge, there's an opening.

No. 4 - Let the season-defining weekends begin ...

No offense to the Big 12 Baseball Tournament, but when your history is as rich as the Texas Baseball program, the event can feel more like a pain in the ass than anything else.

I'm sure it feels different to others with less history, just like it did when the Texas Basketball team celebrated its Big 12 Tournament win back in March (that actually happened!), but win or lose - the real season in Austin begins this week.

Bring on the NCAA postseason. How this team will ultimately be remembered hasn't even started to be written, so there's no reason to say anything more, other than perhaps these three words for a team favored to return to Omaha.

Bring it on.

No. 5 - A man of the people...

First, it was a day of chickenshit bingo at The Little Longhorn Saloon.

View attachment 1104

This weekend, Beard was barnstorming the Mean-eyed Cat.

View attachment 1105

Beard appears determined to sell out his home arena by making connections at every prominent watering hole in the city.

And I ain't mad at him at all.

Next up: Time to go two-stepping at the Spoke.

No. 6a - A season comes to an end...

When it was all said and done on Sunday afternoon in a 2-0 season-ending loss in Stillwater, it felt like Mike White had taken the Texas softball team about as far as it was going to go.

The 2021 Longhorns were very good, but never quite elite.

All one had to do was look at the results against Oklahoma State to realize there was simply another gear that OSU had that this year's Longhorns didn't.

Seven times these teams played each other this season and six times the Longhorns came away on the losing side. At some point you just have to tip your cap to the better team and acknowledge you simply weren't good enough against a team that stood in the way of accomplishing your goals.

In five of those games, the Longhorns failed to score more than two runs, and in four of them, they failed to score more than one. Texas could hit, but they couldn't hit like those teams north of the state border, which is why its season is over.

No. 6b - Another 2021 natty...

Everything I know about Texas rowing, @BlakeSkaggs taught me over the weekend.

2017: 4th (nationally)
2018: 3rd
2019: 2nd

After huffing and puffing for three consecutive seasons, the Texas rowing team finally blew the damn door down. Much respect.


No. 7 – BUY or SELL …



(Sell) I think we'll see an undefeated team emerge from some place, but the quarterback situations across the country certainly have opened up some doors, at least potentially. This has the looks of a year where the subjectiveness of it all is going to likely be front and center. You can close your eyes and hear the national media asking if a two-loss SEC team should get in over a one-loss Big 12 champion, clear as day.



(Sell) Only if they televise the after-party drinking.



(Buy) Texas didn't stink last year. It just wasn't elite. Those last couple of steps are often the hardest to take. Just ask Mack Brown.



(Sell) I still have some concerns about where the pass rush and turnovers come from.



(Buy) Maybe not much more than that, but 500 feels like it might be about right.



(Sell) Maybe in some states like Georgia, but not in all states. Certainly not in Texas.



(Sell) Deep down I think the answer might be a buy, but Sarkisian might run the clock down on an announcement so late in the month of August that the season starts with both.



(Sell) That feels a little flimsy to me. Even Saban struggled in year one to a degree.



(Sell) I don't see that happening.



(Sell) I feel like I buy this every off-season, and it never quite happens. You'll forgive me for not taking it for granted with a new staff just because.



(Buy) Sure. Give me all of it.



(Buy) It being possible isn't the issue. How realistic it is feels like the ultimate question.



(Sell) If it hasn't happened by September 1, it'll be time to panic. Maybe even August if commits start flying off the board by then, as expected.


(Sell) Recruits are tired of gimmicks. They don't want the next upgraded version of the pool party. They want to win championships and get developed into NFL players. The elite dudes aren't falling for the banana in the tailpipe pool party. Ask the Brockermeyers.

No. 8 - Scattershooting on the sports weekend...

... Julio Jones to the Seahawks? The idea set up the Tweet of the Weekend as far as I'm concerned.


... There's a part of me that kind of wants to see Chris Paul make it out of the West this season. How ironic would that be?

... Good week for the Sixers. Really glad we're avoiding the Bucks in the second round, though. I'm totally content with letting the Nets and Bucks kill each other before the conference finals.

... New York was actually on fire over this Knicks team, and Trae Young and Co. might bounce them in five. lol.

... My Phillies have a -23 run differential. That's so depressing.

... I know Astros fans are kind of on tilt about Fernando Tatis Jr., but this home run over the weekend with the Padres down three runs with two outs in the top of the ninth inning was pretty dope to this observer. I wish I had seen it in person.


... After starting her career with the Dallas Wings with a double-double against Los Angeles, Charli Collier has posted the following points/rebounds combos in the last four games: 2/0, 5/5, 3/0 and 6/4. Welcome to the Association, kid.

... I literally paid zero attention to the Indianapolis 500 this weekend.

... I want to get excited about the US national team and then I remember that our coach is just a guy and there's a pace of play that we just never seem to quite catch up to.

... A number of random thoughts from Saturday's Champions League Final...

a. As a Liverpool fan, I found myself not quite caring that Chelsea won, as long as Manchester City remained trophy-less in the competition. Weirdly, Chelsea winning just didn't feel as threatening as seeing Man City win this particular double. It feels a little Aggy-ish, but it is what it is.

b. Props to Chelsea. I have no passive-aggressive shade to dish out. When it was all said and done, Chelsea went through the Spanish champions (Atletico), the Spanish runner-up and the English champion to get over the line. Nothing but respect. Liverpool didn't have that kind of run in them this season.

c. N'Golo Kante is an all-time great player that rarely seems to get ranked like one by the media, even though he's as lovable as a damn teddy bear. His ability to stand up to anyone in the sport in a phone booth is remarkable. You go in with your keys and wallet, and when you leave you have neither.

d. I felt horrible for Kevin de Bruyne that his season basically ended with a broken face, but it also needs to be said that he had not been able to get his grip on the game in any capacity before departing the game. It always felt like he was on the cusp of creating something, but Kante would take it away from him. Forgive me if I stop just short of the Steven Gerrard comparisons.

e. I hope that loss crushes City's spirit going into next season. It's going to be hard for that group of guys to come out of the Euros ready for the grind after the demands of the last four seasons.

f. I say that and City might just spend 500 million this year. Grealish. Kane. Pele. Johan Cruyff from the grave. All of them.

No. 9 - My Top 10 List of Bands that I've Never Done a Deep Dive on But Probably Need To...

So, I don't know if you know this or not, but I started a bit of an online riot with this thread on the band Oasis.

elmo%2Bshrug%2Bgif.gif


The truth of the matter is that I asked a question about the group because outside of the stuff they are best known for in the mid to late 90s, I've just never given the group more than a sideways glance.

Hey, I'm guessing we all have an occasional blind spot or two and I'm willing to give some benefit of the doubt to the idea that there's more to this group than freaking "Wonderwall".

In fact, I plan on doing a deep dive on the band and doing a Top 10 list next Sunday.

For now I'll give you my list of the top 10 bands/singers that I probably need to do a deep dive on. Consider them potential blind spots. It's not that I don't dig some of the music created by this list of 10, it's just that I've never quite gotten the fuss, beyond the obvious.

10. Jane's Addiction
9. Green Day
8. ABBA
7. Oasis
6. Elvis Costello
5. James Taylor
4. Nine Inch Nails
3. Lil Wayne
2. R.E.M.
1. Simon and Garfunkel

No. 10 - And Finally ...

20 years ago on Saturday, a little website called The-University.com sprung up from the Rivals.com ashes of bankruptcy to become the place that I have called home for most of my adult years.

From the 2001 Big 12 Championship game to the Vince Young recruitment to the Vince Young era to blue drinks to Garrett Gilbert predictions to the Big 12 Missile Crisis to It's Austin to 85-percent and to a decade of mostly nothing but disappointment, this place has seen more than I can almost comprehend.

A number of you have been with me every step of the way or close to it, and I just wanted to take a moment to thank those of you that have been the hardest of the hardcores.

I know I can be kind of a pain in the ass from time to time. You riding shotgun with me during nearly the entire emergence of the Internet's explosion has never been taken for granted.

Thank you.

Here's to another 20 years, this time with more championships to celebrate.
Great job now yall get started getting dirt on all these top programs and help us land these top players. Think if we had just this year and last years top players to stay in Texas We have Milroe and the Southlake kid and then all the top OL 5 last year 5 this year then top 2 RB and then Top WR we would be set on Def to win big.
 
Normally I’d say that’s some tin foil hat stuff going on with your QB reps in the spring game stuff, but Sark has to try to keep both somehow and he was never going to outright name a starter until he had to. I still don’t know if you can sacrifice reps for a guy that needs them and you clearly think can be special with reps just for the sake of appearances. I agree that he can’t name a starter until game week for several reasons.
Wish we could make a trade. Our losing QB for a top DE and S and OL.
 
Do ABBA, and don’t buy the scorn you’ll get. Bjorn and Benny were the Swedish version of John and Paul.

I’ve been here every step of the way, though I think my time stamp is off a couple of months. Took me a bit to sign up after the demise of TheUniversity.com because I was working in Europe. You and Such are the best. So glad you snagged him from Horns Illustrated back in the day. Here’s to 20 more years! 🤘
 
  • Like
Reactions: styrbjorn
I can bring up the pick six because it was bad but go back & watch the Utep game where he score on 2 of his 3 drives. I mean this kid has threw TD’s or lead to scores on 7 or 8 of his live game opportunities & has performed pretty well in both other spring games as well since on the forty. Most of you pumping Card only have 1 or 2 passes in the recent spring game to point to but you all also never bring up his bad plays & bounce passes & his misreads but the minute he throws a 6 yd TD pass. All of you have him as a Heisman candidate & 1st round selection. Obviously I’m just not a member of the good ole boy club & seems like Thompson can’t win either way with this crew! No wonder we have struggled with a top notch Qb to get us back where we belong. Some of you need to just keep your day job & leave coaching to those that know how to truly evaluate them. This isn’t a popularity contest amongst the Good ole Boy Club!.🤔🤔
Good ole Boy Club? WTF. Who gives a damn about great play against frickin UTEP. It proves absolutely nothing. You don't seem to like the fact that Card has a lot of ability. Whether he takes the job is another matter. We'll see.
 
@Ketchum ive been meaning to ask where you and the National guys would’ve ranked Sanders if his size and athleticism wasn’t considered when projecting a future DE. TE only, you think he’s still too 30 nationally? Top 5 LSR?
 
I don’t think it’s subjective analysis to say Bomar, Shep and Gilbert grossly underperformed in college relative to the rankings as QBs out of HS.
Most players do, I suppose.
 
Good ole Boy Club? WTF. Who gives a damn about great play against frickin UTEP. It proves absolutely nothing. You don't seem to like the fact that Card has a lot of ability. Whether he takes the job is another matter. We'll see.
Oh, it’s obvious you don’t care about UTEP or Colorado but it’s Def more than the ______ well you get the point. I have no issue with Card & his abilities. I wish the kid all the luck in the world for all the success he could possibly have in his career. Just seems all want to discredit thompson for 1 pick six & boast card for 1 6 yd TD. Coaches will decide so it’s all good but I like to call a spade, a spade!
 
@Ketchum ive been meaning to ask where you and the National guys would’ve ranked Sanders if his size and athleticism wasn’t considered when projecting a future DE. TE only, you think he’s still too 30 nationally? Top 5 LSR?
yes
 
Do ABBA, and don’t buy the scorn you’ll get. Bjorn and Benny were the Swedish version of John and Paul.

I’ve been here every step of the way, though I think my time stamp is off a couple of months. Took me a bit to sign up after the demise of TheUniversity.com because I was working in Europe. You and Such are the best. So glad you snagged him from Horns Illustrated back in the day. Here’s to 20 more years! 🤘
A Horns Illustrated reference?!?! Man , you have been around for a while! ;)

Thank you!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Type O
I guess I missed where Sanders is slated for TE.
 
Perhaps. But the focus is on your QB picks. In fairness, EVERY recruiting analyst missed on those guys.
It's an interesting conversation.

Shepard is a good example.

He was never rated as a five-star quarterback because of his arm talent. He was rated as a five-star because of his athletic skill set (similar to VY).

He ends up playing seven seasons in the NFL, which is no short order, which means that we correctly nailed that his talent had serious Sunday upside, but he was just a spare part at LSU no matter how you slice it, regardless of position.

It's like being right and wrong at the same time.

Bomar is another interesting case because he got suspended from the Big Red Auto scandal, an issue less problematic for OU than him when the dust settled. I wonder how the OU story of the next few years unfolds if Sam Bradford is blocked by Bomar.
 
I hope you are right about Card, but I also remember everyone being all-in on Garret Gilbert. And I remember watching Gilbert's HS tape and wondering if a guy with that slow delivery would make it in Big Boy football. In retrospect, maybe GG would have been well served to have a QB competition instead of getting handed the job on a platter.

I understand the love for Card, and also for Thompson. I am excited to see either or both of them run Sark's offense. But I don't understand a lot of the folks in this thread saying with such certainty which of those two is going to be the guy. Maybe Sark knows that, but I sure as hell don't.
 
  • Like
Reactions: horns_90
I hope you are right about Card, but I also remember everyone being all-in on Garret Gilbert. And I remember watching Gilbert's HS tape and wondering if a guy with that slow delivery would make it in Big Boy football. In retrospect, maybe GG would have been well served to have a QB competition instead of getting handed the job on a platter.

I understand the love for Card, and also for Thompson. I am excited to see either or both of them run Sark's offense. But I don't understand a lot of the folks in this thread saying with such certainty which of those two is going to be the guy. Maybe Sark knows that, but I sure as hell don't.
I also think Gilbert shouldn't have been rushed back from shoulder injuries in HS and rushed into action in college.

He had some circumstances that went against him.
 
I also think Gilbert shouldn't have been rushed back from shoulder injuries in HS and rushed into action in college.

He had some circumstances that went against him.
Absolutely agree. I also think it hurt us badly that we played close games against so many poor teams in 2009. Gilbert got virtually no reps prior to the NC game with Bama. He was not really put into a position to succeed.

But my point, I guess, is that everyone was convinced Gilbert was a "can't miss" prospect, which really didn't pan out. I really hope you are right about Card, and I really hope Thompson is a s good as some folks on here think. But I'm not prepared - based on the tiny sample set we have seen - to anoint either of them as the clear leader in the QB competition.
 
Absolutely agree. I also think it hurt us badly that we played close games against so many poor teams in 2009. Gilbert got virtually no reps prior to the NC game with Bama. He was not really put into a position to succeed.

But my point, I guess, is that everyone was convinced Gilbert was a "can't miss" prospect, which really didn't pan out. I really hope you are right about Card, and I really hope Thompson is a s good as some folks on here think. But I'm not prepared - based on the tiny sample set we have seen - to anoint either of them as the clear leader in the QB competition.
No one is can't-miss. Too many uncontrollable factors can occur... and some controllable ones, too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: styrbjorn
ADVERTISEMENT