The caveat being that they would all be fighting each other at their age and shape they were in while in office. A guy like Gerald Ford was a D1 athlete, but he was pretty old and fat while in office, so doubtful he could hold his own. JFK, while young and appeared to be in good shape while in office, was pretty beat up while in office, so I excluded him.
The 3 I came up with are:
Teddy Roosevelt - Relatively young while in office and was probably still in decent shape. Was an avid outdoorsman and led the Roughriders.
Lincoln - Relatively young while in office. Apparently a badass wrestler. Was tall and boney, so you know it would hurt like hell when he hit you with those gangly hands.
George Washington - Was only in his 50s while in office, but that was ancient at the time. Was a big dude and was battle tested, so I imagine he could hold his own in a fight.
Wild Card is 43. I think he has some junkyard dog in him.
The 3 I came up with are:
Teddy Roosevelt - Relatively young while in office and was probably still in decent shape. Was an avid outdoorsman and led the Roughriders.
Lincoln - Relatively young while in office. Apparently a badass wrestler. Was tall and boney, so you know it would hurt like hell when he hit you with those gangly hands.
George Washington - Was only in his 50s while in office, but that was ancient at the time. Was a big dude and was battle tested, so I imagine he could hold his own in a fight.
Wild Card is 43. I think he has some junkyard dog in him.
