Hey you were a former coach. Has a time of possession based offense always been popular or is this a new trend? Those 3 big SEC upsets were won by teams who had a big edge. It has really given less talented teams a better chance at winning. It isn't just the SEC it's BYU, Indiana and other schools. Bill Snyder's teams were built around it.
On the surface it doesn't seem complicated. Top, execution, few penalties and turnovers. Hey yesterday was the first time all season Vanderbilt had any turnovers. It's like they have a play that they'll run 4 different ways just like Snyder's teams. And of course it shortens the game for a defense just force a couple of turnovers.
You have an opinion?
Always been popular. It is even less now, but schemes are cyclical.
The ole Wing T, Slot T, Wishbone, Flexbone, I, split back, etc., etc. were all designed for winning the TOP.
Hal Mumme is who I consider the father of the spread as we know it today. That morphed into the, "if we score on more of our possessions than our opponent then we win"
As far as the throws close to the LOS and to the numbers on the LOS or behind it? Coaches that have that as a staple of their offense see it as a risk vs. reward. Generally, worst case scenario you're expecting a 3-4 yard gain minimum, which is just as good as a run between the tackles.
Another thing about TOP, it is more important to the teams that don't have the talent and dynamic skill position players, but just enough to bust some 20+ plays. Teams that have a major advantage in that talent department generally aren't as concerned about TOP.
As far as Snyder, he was an offensive genius and for my money, the one that perfected the QB centered run game. Zone read, or whatever you want to call it. Rich Rod sometimes gets credit, but for me it was Bill Snyder. Snyder believed in run to set up big plays in the pass game. But year to year, his pct of run/pass would change. What made Snyder great as an offensive guy, even going back to Iowa, is that he adapted to his personnel. He was a master. And I think you're spot on about Vandy and Snyder comparison. Tim Beck is their OC, which is hilarious because he was considered a disaster at Texas. I thought he was pretty decent given the fact the OL sucked and his boss was a douche.
Dead ball penalties are a sign of poor discipline and a lack of confidence. Holds happen. False Starts, illegal formations, etc. are all prep and discipline.
Opinion, I prefer a Snyder offense over a Leach type offense. I don't mind the quick screens and bubbles, etc. I like the risk vs. reward. And when you have a WR corps like we do, get those dudes the ball quickly and in space. However, Sark needs to make some adjustments are start implementing some extensions off of those staple plays.
We need #9 healthy at RB and to be what he is expected to be, or QE and O will continue to struggle in spots.