Then let's just admit Strong was a place holder or brought in to get good recruiting classes. Because no coach was doing much better with the talent on the team in year 1 and 2. I get that everyone wants to beleive had we brought in Saban, or whoever things would be better, and maybe they would be THIS year. Not so much last year or the year before.
Look, I actually agree with part of your point. I'm of the school that doesn't think we'd be in the national title this year regardless of the coach, and I think that building from the ground up was something might need to have happened at Texas regardless of the hire.
Coming into this season, my thought was: this should be a fun year... but we should really be back next year, not this year. 8 wins or so. 10 would be a really great season, but if he gets 7 and things look like they're progressing, I'm in for the 4th year. 8 and I'm in regardless.
After winning the Notre Dame game, my thought was, wow, it's great to see the team fight back from behind and win a game like that. They didn't quit. I like that. But let's not get ahead of ourselves here. It's just one game. I still expect some losses this year. The rest of the conference looking suspect makes me tempted to start thinking way bigger, but I really don't like the jump in the polls that we made. It was just one win so far.
But these first 6 weeks of the season (5 games and a bye) looked a little make-or break, in part because they needed to show improvement, and in part because having one big home game, one small home game, and then 3 games away from home over 4 weeks... I mean, if there's a bad trend during that, then by the time the team is back in the home stadium, Texas fans are going to have already made up their mind.
If I were only basing my thoughts on all of this on the offensive improvements, we'd be golden. Yeah, there are some things to work on with the receivers. Yeah, once in a while I'm not sure why a certain play is called when something else is working so well. But improvement? No doubt! But the issues we're having on defense aren't new. They've been there. And they seem like they're getting worse, not better. And... isn't that kind of why we hired Coach Strong?
I like the guy. I've been a big supporter since his hire. I've suggested he needs more time when people were freaking out last year. And yes, I realize how crazy it is that one year counts as "more time". In an ideal world he'd have even more time than that. It's not really so much that we lost games. It's how we lost them. Last year, for me, it was "wow, we were so close to winning those two games! A little tweaking, and we should be several games better! And imagine if we had a more versatile quarterback situation!" This year we have a MUCH better QB situations, and those two games that were just a tweak or two away from being wins... are suddenly losses where we didn't look like we could handle the game at all.
Now, I'm still willing to watch the team and see if things get better for as long as Coach Strong is the head coach. And if somehow it all starts coming around, I'll be ecstatic. I really would love for that to be the way this story goes. But I also think that it IS time for the powers that be to start figuring out what they want to do, including the possibility of finding a new coach. I think the specifics on how quickly or how urgently they should act would be based on things that I couldn't possibly know enough about, like who else they would consider and what opportunities there are, as well as how donors and recruits are reacting at this point. I'm definitely not in the "fire him right now" camp and as long as he's the coach, I'll continue to hope things get better... but I'm also think it's a totally appropriate time for the powers-that-be to be asking "do we think he can fix it? at what point do we start losing recruits and fan interest? who else is out there and do we have reason to think they'd do better now?"
Losing games is one thing, but there's just no reason that the team should look this helpless in our middle-tier match-ups. Especially when some of the issues are clearly the same issues we've been having for a while now.