ADVERTISEMENT

Liberal Democrats turning into conservatives . . .

From liberal Democrats John B. Judis’s and Ruy Teixeira’s new book, Where Have All the Democrats Gone?:

[T]he New Deal Democrats were moderate and even small-c conservative in their social outlook. They extolled "the American way of life" (a term popularized in the 1930s); they used patriotic symbols like the "Blue Eagle" to promote their programs. In 1940, Roosevelt's official campaign song was Irving Berlin's "God Bless America." Under Roosevelt, Thanksgiving, Veterans' Day, and Columbus Day were made into federal holidays. Roosevelt turned the annual Christmas Tree lighting into a national event. Roosevelt's politics were those of "the people" (a term summed up in Carl Sandburg's 1936 poem, "The People, Yes") and of the "forgotten American." There wasn't a hint of multiculturalism or tribalism. The Democrats need to follow this example.

Supreme Court takes up Colorado Trump case

Login to view embedded media
The pragmatic and "correct" outcome in my opinion would be to rule it is a political issue to be decided by the voters.

However, the WSJ has a story today about the quandary this presents the conservative majority. They have generally been steadfast in strict " textualism and originalism" interpretations of the constitution. They are not fans of pragmatic applications, even when it arguably could lead to chaos:


"The conservative majority, including Chief Justice John Roberts, considers itself textualist and originalist, and conservative legal scholars such as Will Baude and Mike Paulsen have argued that textualism and originalism argue in favor of disqualifying Trump from office. The text of the Fourteenth Amendment is self-executing, they argue, and allows state officials to decide who has “engaged in insurrection” as they see fit, without enabling legislation from Congress. Both the Colorado and Maine decisions relied on Congress’s conclusion in its January 6 report that Trump had aided or assisted the insurrection.

. . .

The election cases will revive the debate between the more pragmatic Chief Justice Roberts and the rest of the conservative majority, which tends to be more devoted to textualism and originalism. In his votes to uphold the Affordable Care Act and to avoid formally overturning Roe v. Wade, Roberts has emphasized the importance of considerations such as respecting precedent or maintaining the Court’s nonpartisan legitimacy."


ADVERTISEMENT

Filter

ADVERTISEMENT