BBA, I can agree with your overall point but I would also argue the same logic applies for you guys. Who would you say is your “signature win”?
-Oregon has a nice resume. Beat Boise and Ohio St. Toughest road game was at Michigan and this week at Wisconsin
-Ohio State has a tough 1 point loss at Oregon. They beat Penn St., but they always do. They have Indiana this week.
-Texas got handled by Georgia. Best wins are at Michigan and at Vandy. Texas will need to win out more than likely to make CFP
-Penn St is doing what they do every year. They are a benefactor of being highly ranked pre-season, lose to Ohio State and get a few close wins on the road against "tough" opponents. Go to a bowl game and get the shit kicked out of them. We need Minnesota to come up clutch and knock these posers out.
-Indiana has a terrible resume. Hardest game is coming up this week. If they get blown away by Ohio State, you can say adios to their playoff hopes. If they have a close loss and then beat Purdue, they are in as an 11-1 team
-BYU should be #3 in my opinion. Undefeated. Win on the road vs. SMU which isn't a terribly hard environment, but still a quality road win. Road win in a rivalry at Utah, who isn't great but still a good win in my opinion. Blew out KState at home.
-Tennessee has a very good win at home vs. Alabama. Non-conference is dog shit. They have a chance this week vs. Georgia to solidify their place. I don't think they win this game, but will finish 10-2 and probably get an at-large spot
-Notre Dame has a very good win at Texas A&M, blew away Navy who is a bit overrated, but still has a nice record. Decent win vs. Louisville. Best remaining game is against Army of all teams, lol. Notre Dame will win out and could end up with a top 4 seed.
-Miami is smoke and mirrors in my opinion, but that QB is so nice. Love his trajectory from little ole Incarnate Word. Benefitted from some iffy calls late in games. Very good second half team. 50/50 on if they make the CFP
-Alabama has 2 losses, but probably the best collection of wins of anyone in the top 10. Beat Georgia, South Carolina, Mizzou and LSU. Went to Wisconsin in non-conference and blew them away. That Vandy loss is a killer.
-Ole Miss has 2 losses as well, but some quality wins too. Wins at SCAR, and at home vs. Georgia are good wins. That Kentucky loss is a killer
So I guess the point I'm making is, almost everyone has a shit resume at this point. Most of these teams have a ranked opponent left and/or a championship game. Most of the teams in the CFP will have earned their way. There will be about 4-5 teams for 3 spots and some bitching about resume, LOL. Doesn't matter how much you expand the playoff, there will always be 1-2 more teams that there are spots and bitching about resumes.
My top 12 right now
1 - Oregon (Big 10 Champ)
2 - BYU (Big 12 Champ)
3 - Notre Dame (Independent)
4 - Alabama (SEC Champ)
5 - Ohio St.
6 - Texas
7 - Tennessee
8 - SMU (ACC Champ)
9 - Penn St.
10 - Ole Miss
11 - Indiana
12 - Boise St.
-----------------
13 - Georgia
14 - Miami
15 - Texas A&M