Good grief Heisenberg.
- I made the comment that I don't see a 5-8 QB being as productive as the #1 draft pick in the NFL draft. I also have stated multiple times that I may be wrong.
- You said that you don't see how height has any reflection on production
- It absolutely has an affect on production. If it didn't then you would see a lot more 5-8 (5-10) QBs
- It is a MAJOR issue when you're 5-8 (5-10, whatever) and trying to see over/through 6-6 to 6-8 guys. It is common freaking sense...especially in football. Murray would be an outlier, not the norm.
- I also understand that being a 5-10 QB doesn't mean you won't be very successful...look at Todd Reesing. This is also the reason that I stated "I may be wrong about Murray"
- Where in the world did I ever say I "have a buddy" and he isn't 5-10? The difference in 5-8 and 5-10 is negligible. The difference in 5-10 and 6-1 as a QB is significant.
- You said Murray was recruited because of his high upside at QB due to his superior athletic abilities. But you're arguing against my point that Murray was recruited because of his superior athletic abilities and he MAY play QB one day in college? It is the same thing, said in a different way. I'd recruit him knowing that if it doesn't work out at QB then he is still a superior athlete that can probably catch the ball a little...much like Jerrod Heard and every other DUAL threat QB coming out of HS.
- Of course Murray committed to play QB, and QB only. He thinks he is a QB. IF he could handle the deficiencies that lack of height causes for a QB, then his athletic ability would be a major asset. Duh.
If Murray was at Texas I would still be skeptical about his ability to perform at an elite level due to his stature. But like I stated above (Todd Reesing) there are examples of QBs being successful at the D1 college football level even though they're "short." Murray's athletic ability is certainly a feather in his cap and if he wins the job at OU I think he will do very well.
I'll take OU and 10 wins with Kyler Murray having a tougher time at QB than some of y'all think. It's not doom and gloom though, LOL.
1. Way to go out on a limb and predict Murray wont be as productive as one of the best cfb qbs who ever played. If you find someone expecting him to produce at the same level, go ahead and piss in his cereal for me.
2. I remember saying that.
3. Height has no bearing on production. 5'10 isnt the height you look for in a qb, you normally want a taller guy. But you can take a 5'10 guy who never lost a game in high school and who has world class athleticism. I dont think all the HCs who offered him are all stupid. There's a reason why a guy his size isnt playing juco ball and you dont seem to get that.
4. Sure, it's not as easy to see over linemen. And that didnt stop barely over 6' Mayfield or a slew of many other sub 6' qbs from being successful. And incase you havent seen football before, you dont have to stand in the pocket 100% of the time. Even though i have seen plenty of video of him throwing beauties from within the pocket surrounded by mammoth beasts. I"m thinking it's probably not as big of a problem as you think as he's been practicing behind giants for a while now.
5. You just really, really, really, really, really, really, REALLY want to be right though. I get the feeling you'd rather lose to Austin Kendall if it meant some texas LBer ended Murray's football career at the RRR
6. Not you necessearily, but just referring to all the hearsay. His measureables at OU and with the A's dispute what people have said. The kind of people who "have buddies" who are close to his high school program and accuse him of barely being 5'8.
7. No, it's not the same thing. He's a qb, always played qb and played very successfully at qb and that was the one and only position he was recruited to play and happens to be the one position he's ever played at this level. So, you saying he's recruited as someone who MAY play qb in college is asinine and incorrect and just an attempt to diminish him as a qb. Behind this Oline and with all the weapons he has at his disposal, he's going to make you glad he's only here for one season
8. Not only does he think he's a qb, but so does everyone else who isnt you apparently. Coaches who know what it takes to be a qb at this level are putting the fate of their team and their jobs in his hands after seeing him in practice for a couple years. Must mean he's pretty good to be out there starting for OU. (assuming he wins the job).
I dont know what kind of time he'll have, tough or not. I know he's looked really really good so far, even if it was just 21 attempts, he completed 18 of them and looked calm and composed and made good decisions. That's all Ou needs out of a him and he'll go above and beyond that