What is everyone's preferred concealed carry pistol? I carry a Ruger LCP because it is small enough to wear with anything and is comfortable, but I doubt I would be very effective at 40 yards to stop a shooter.
An LCP is fine as a backup gun or as a primary CCW when attire so dictates (though I really hate the sights and trigger on the first-generation model), but I definitely prefer something more substantial than a .380 "mouse gun" whenever possible.
I'm still waiting for my ideal CCW to be produced. My sentimental favorite CCW is my
Walther PPS M1 in 9mm, because (for me) it shoots like a full-size pistol at 15 and 25 yards, is very soft-shooting even with +P rounds, has a terrific trigger (for a striker-fired plastic gun), and fits my hands well with the largest back strap installed. I also love the paddle-style mag release on a CCW, which eliminates any accidental mag drops from banging into stuff while carrying, and which allows dropping spent mags without breaking one's grip. It's hard to overlook its capacity disadvantage these days, though. The baseplates on the mags are also more prone to snag on clothing than most and make carrying backup mags a bit of a PITA.
The
P365 is everyone's favorite now, but the grip is way too small for my hands, especially front to back. I'm also not a big fan of striker-fired guns that lack a trigger safety, and trigger pull weight is close to being too light for my tastes for this type of pistol (especially with no trigger dingus), at least on some. I've shot several of them over the last few years, and I've found trigger weights to be pretty inconsistent from gun to gun, with some right at 5 lbs. and some as high as 7 lbs.
I tried the
Glock 43X with with S15 steel mags (15 rounds, obviously) and steel mag catch by Shield Arms, but I just could not achieve satisfactory reliability with them. Most people report no trouble with the S15 mags, but some folks have issues with them, and I'm unfortunately in the latter group. I like the G43X, but if I'm going to carry a gun with a G19-length grip, then I'd usually rather just carry a G19.
My current placeholder CCW is the
Springfield Hellcat, which is the P365's best direct competition, holding one more round (11+1 with standard mags, 13+1 with extended) in a roughly equivalently sized package. The grip works far better for my large hands, as it isn't so short from front to back, and its trigger characteristics are much more to my liking. I have a bit of a prejudice against these Croatian (HS Produkt) imports, but it's not really rational, because other HS Produkt guns (all of the various XD series pistols) have an excellent track record.
What I'd really like is for Walther to wake up and release a PPS M3 with the same 1.5-stack configuration as the Hellcat and P365. (Bringing back the paddle release, at least as an option, would be nice, but that's probably asking too much.) There are also never-ending rumors that
HK is going to finally release something in this category, which I'd love to see, but they're generally as slow as anyone to respond to civilian market demands.