Too many unkowns with freshmen. Vince and Colt had a very strong and experienced team on both sides of the ball. Sam was not impressive in the least his freshman and sophomore years. I get what you are saying and you may be right. However, are we for sure on the upside being that much of a difference? Let's remember the 4* vs 5* ranking is not an absolute.But on the flip side look at Vince, Colt, and Sam what they did as freshman. You can’t just not start a guy because he’s a freshman. If it’s as close as it sounds like it is then you go with the guy who has the higher ceiling. That’s obviously Ewers. I think it’s a big difference from being a redshirt freshman and a true freshman. Both Vince and Sam redshirted a year and I think that was beneficial to them. Same with Ewers.