No one is comparing the plight. We're comparing the slur. Neither blacks, Hispanics, or Asians had that indentical plight either, and it's not okay to go around using ethnic slurs towards them either.Originally posted by Ketchum:
Considering some view the name as a racist slur, yes, I would say it's in the overtly racist category.Originally posted by Ignatius J Reilly:
I don't believe for a second that you think the Clippers owner overtly being racist and the Redskins name is apples to apples either.
I disagree.Originally posted by Ignatius J Reilly:
My comparison is a hell of a lot more apples to apples than the connection your trying to make.
Like I said, those depictions should also be changed. It's not needed in 2014.Originally posted by Ignatius J Reilly:
Yes, native Irish people were discriminated against for a long time in America, with the backbone of that being a stereotype of being dirty drunks who liked to fight. Yankees and Fightin' Irish are derogatory terms depending on the context, just like Redskin is.
That being said, I wouldn't compare the plight of the Irish in America with that of the Native Americans, unless there's a chapter in American history where the Irish were slaughtered, had their property seized from them and were marginalized in society to embarrassing levels that I somehow missed.
This comes from someone with a lot of Irish family members.
Yes, the Irish in America were discriminated against. It's forgotten as a lot of assimilation has taken place, but even though "No Irish Need Apply" hasn't been posted in over hundred years, we are not that far removed from JFK being elected President being a Roman Catholic marked a big step forward for tolerance in America.
The bottom line is that if you're going to be ultra-sensitive about race, you need to streamline it and not tolerate any slurs equally. In the context of the Washington Redskins as a football organization, there is no intended racism. If you don't think the slur itself should stand, then take away any team whose name can be construed as a slur in another context.