I think the only time I've been in this much agreement with you over a list was the Eva Cassidy list...No. 10 - The List: Keanu Reeves Top 10 ...
Honorable Mention: River's Edge, Parenthood, Dangerous Liaisons, The Replacements, Hardball and A Walk in the Clouds,
10. Toy Story 4
9. Something's Gotta Give
8. The Devil's Advocate
7. John Wick: Chapter 2
6. Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure
5. My Own Private Idaho
4. John Wick
3. Speed
2. Point Break
1. The Matrix
I'd have to figure out a way to get A Scanner Darkly in there - maybe at 10 or maybe just in the HM portion. But this is obviously just a minor quibble and personal preference if we're talking about squeezing in a pretty niche movie into HMs. He stretched his acting legs in "The Gift" and was really quite good in it but the only thing that makes that movie worth rewatching is Katie Holmes transformation from dorky-but-cute Joey Potter into [PAUSE/SLOW-MOTION/REPEAT] goddess (if you know, you know). Note: If you don't know, Katie Holmes had a Alexandra Daddario moment for the VHS/DVD crowd in this film.
As for the actual rankings... The top-4 are the top-4. His best acting is the work he did in My Own Private Idaho. I had no idea people talked smack about The Devil's Advocate. So yeah, good top-10, Ketch.