ADVERTISEMENT

Ketch's 10 Thoughts From The Weekend (Sark isn't getting enough credit for this...)

ee0e3a40b744e2eebc3b4d949eaa9055x.jpg
Texas coach Steve Sarkisian has it cooking in recruiting for the Longhorns in his first season, which isn't surprising when you consider that I predicted he would sign a top five class in 2022.

Still, I feel like we need to take a moment and show some appreciation for this staff's ability to create momentum almost out of thin air upon their arrival. Both Charlie Strong and Tom Herman had excellent rankings in their collective first recruiting class, but it took 5-6 months for both to find serious footing and results.

Sarkisian and Co. have been able to do it in 5-6 weeks, which has been critical when you realize how many top 2022 prospects in Texas have already started making decisions.

If you take a look at my recent Lone Star Recruiting Top 100 List, you'll find that three of the top five, five of the top nine and 12 of the top 22 prospects in the state have already made decisions. That's 55 percent.

Ready or not, the elite of the elite are making decisions early in Sarkisian's tenure.

To their credit, Sarkisian's staff have been more than ready.

No. 2 - The top remaining in-state options...

This list will evolve over the next 11 months, and there will be a few newcomers making breakthroughs in the rankings, especially in a COVID-dominated recruiting world, but with every passing year, it is stunning to see so many of the top names in the debut of each set of rankings end up near the top when the rankings are finished two years later.

With that in mind, here's a look at the top 15 remaining uncommitted prospects in the state by position. (LSR ranking in parenthesis)

* Players in bold have been offered or re-offered by the Texas staff

Quarterbacks

(1) Cade Klubnik (Austin Westlake)


(26) Alex Orji (Sachse)

Running Backs

(18) Jamarion Miller (Tyler Legacy)

(23) Tavorus Jones (El Paso Burges)

Wide Receivers


None

Tight Ends

None

Offensive Linemen

(6) Kam Dewberry (Humble Atascocita)

(10 Devon Campbell (Arlington Bowie)

(11) Kelvin Banks (Houston Summer Creek)

(25) Neto Umeozulu (Allen)

Defensive Linemen

(7) Omari Abor (Duncanville)

(24) Jaray Bledsoe (Bremond)

(27) Ernest Cooper (Arlington Martin)

Linebackers

(14) Harold Perkins (Cypress Park)

Defensive Backs

(2) Denver Harris (North Shore)

(15) Bryce Anderson (Beaumont Westbrook)

Athletes

(19) Brenen Thompson (Spearman)

No. 3 - Some impressions on the top remaining prospects ...


* Those four offensive line prospects are pretty much everything in this class considering what happened a year ago. Of course, the Longhorns could hit on an out-of-state guy or two, and there's always a chance that a player emerges from the shadows of the early rankings and becomes a Top 15-25 level prospect, but Banks, Campbell, Dewberry and Umeozulu (ranked in any order you want) are at the core of what this 2022 class will need in order to become a true success.

* Not including Klubnik, the skill position group is thin in impact prospects. The highest-rated skill player remaining (running backs/wide receivers/tight ends) is Miller at No. 18. The importance of the Jaydon "Don't Call Him Alfred" Blue and Evan Stewart commitments cannot be overstated, as they were the last two remaining offensive skill prospects remaining from the five-star and high four-star tiers of the rankings; Brenen Thompson could end up in that area, while technically being recruited as an athlete by a lot of schools.

* The importance of Jason Llewellyn as a prospect is probably impacted by his profile and the scarcity of players at his position. Still, the Longhorns are loaded at the wide receiver position, so if there was ever a year where they could survive a lack of tight end prospects, it's in 2022. Look for Jeff Banks to stay on Llewellyn, while looking for an out-of-state guy to poach; most of the tight ends in Texas look like developmental projects with somewhat limited upside.

* Barring a flip of Bear Alexander or Malick Sylla, the Longhorns aren’t going to fill their needs along the defensive line from the Lone Star State alone. Only Duncanville's Abor remains as an elite option.

* Historically, the value of linebackers is suspect, to say the least, but Perkins is clearly the apple of everyone's eye at his position.

* Denver Harris and Bryce Anderson are in the discussion for best remaining prospects, but there's a pile of defensive backs right outside of the top 25 that does give this position more depth than the top 15 might suggest. Aledo's Bryan Allen, Katy's Bobby Taylor, Plano John Paul's Terrance Brooks and Garland's Chace Biddle would all be in the next 10. I personally view Harris and Alexander on different, higher tiers than the others.

No. 4 - Four weekend thoughts on Maalik Murphy ...

1. While I have Klubnik and Quinn Ewers ranked as five-star quarterback prospects, I'm not sure that either are in the same league as Murphy when it comes to his physical profile and ability to throw the football on an absolute line.

Take a look at this freaking throw and its trajectory. For all of Ewers’ accuracy (and he could end up being the most accurate prospect the state has produced in a decade), he doesn't quite throw the ball consistently like this.



2. I'm really having a hard time coming up with a name for a former Longhorn that Murphy reminds me off. Maybe Chris Simms to a degree, but I think Murphy throws the intermediate and deep intermediate ball better than Simms did at the same age.

3. Watching him throw in 7-on-7 feels like watching an elite power hitter take batting practice.

4. He's got the Hook'em down correctly. This is important.

maalik-murphy-jpg.630


No. 5 - About 2022 Defensive Back Recruiting ...

If you inspect the plan for the Texas defensive backfield, you'll find that the commitment of Landon Hullaby to Oregon won’t impact the recruiting class much. Consider:

a. The Longhorns will probably take between 4-6 defensive backs, depending on the hit rate at the top of their board. The betting favorite would probably be five defensive backs, but if Texas gets everyone, they'd probably make room for a sixth difference maker. Four feels on the light side and might mean a commitment peeled off, or Texas missed on more players than anticipated.

b. With Port Arthur Memorial's Jaylon Guilbeau already committed, you'd have to think that the staff has two spots reserved for Bryce Anderson and Denver Harris.

c. A commitment by Hullaby would have left the program with less positional versatility in its remaining offers, considering Texas has offered 22 higher-rated players at the position thus far in the 2022 class. Hullaby is a really good prospect, but there's a chance that spot will be filled with a prospect with a higher/more valuable profile.

d. The reality of there being fewer spots available might create some urgency on those final spots in the remaining field of offers.

No. 6 - Uh oh ...

If there's one thing you can say with 100-percent certainty about long-time followers of the Texas men's basketball program, we can spot a late-season collapse coming a mile away.

The program has shown a repeated ability to steal a sad ending from the jaws of a successful season.

So, when the team's inconsistent form turned into a disaster against West Virginia that included an embarrassing argument between two upperclassmen/leaders of the team and blowing a 19-point lead, well.... you'll have to excuse us when we all run into the nearest room and yell, "FIIIIRRRRRREEEEEE!!!!!!!"

For most of this season, I have firmly believed that Texas would make a run in the NCAA Tournament for the first time in a decade, but this was a collapse.

The way this team fumbled and bumbled its way through the final 10 minutes was not the stuff of future NCAA Tournament success, and typically those types of runs come from a team starting to play its best basketball right about now. You won't find many college backcourts with as much experience as the trio of Matt Coleman, Andrew Jones and Courtney Ramey, which is why I've been so confident in this group in an early NCAA Tournament setting, but the decision-making and execution from this trio on Saturday was u-g-l-y.

Jones had a poor game that featured a ton of turnovers (6) and missed shots (12), several of which inexplicably felt like mistimed heat checks. Ramey was in NBA Jam "Fire Mode" when he was suckered into committing his fifth foul at a time when the team couldn't afford to lose him. Meanwhile, Coleman ruined a great shooting night when he missed the front end of a 1-and-1 that could have allowed Texas to tie the game at 84-84 with less than 10 seconds left.

Everyone following the program is preparing for the worst because it’s what we have been conditioned to expect.

It's not that this team can't make a run; it would just be insanity to expect different results and not the same thing over and over again.

No. 7 – BUY or SELL …


(Buy) I don't buy it with much confidence, though.


(Sell) I'm more worried about the closing out of the game on Saturday than the dust-up on the sidelines. It was embarrassing, but this team hasn't been playing its best basketball for a while now.


(Sell) Is this what people are saying? I think there's more excitement going down on the offensive side of the ball at the moment, which is understandable, but I don't expect this class to be dominated by its offensive prospects alone. I didn't view the Hullaby commitment as anything other than an opportunity.


(Buy) He's more game-ready right now.


(Buy) Yes and yes.


(Buy) I don't like it.


(Sell) I think common sense indicates there's a good chance of that.


(Buy) The portal will be busy.


(Buy) No question.


(Sell) I believe they are equal-sized pieces of the puzzle.


(Sell) Die Hard isn't a Christmas movie, but it is the superior movie.


(Buy) You misspelled decades.

No. 8 - Scattershooting on the world of sports...

... It sucks that the career of Charli Collier likely won't end with a better supporting cast; Vic Schaefer will eventually bring in that kind of talent.

... Tanking all of those seasons to have a chance to see Joel Embiid have a 50-piece to go along with 17 rebounds on Friday night in the middle of a potential MVP season was worth it.

... This will never get old.


... I don't get the "Carson Wentz makes the Colts a Super Bowl threat" talk at all.

... I read a mock draft on Sunday and I can honestly say that I'm not yet in draft-mode at all.

... Can't say I was surprised to see that Derrick Lewis knocked someone out this weekend. Can't say I know what Curtis Blaydes was thinking in terms of his approach.

... Novak Djokovic won No. 18 this weekend. Here's hoping he doesn't get to No. 20. Signed, a Nadal homer.

... It feels like the era of Naomi Osaka is truly upon us.

.... I feel like I'm reliving the 1999 season for the Dallas Cowboys as a Liverpool FC fan, with the injury fallout from losing Michel Irvin looking similar to what has happened since the injury to Virgil Van Dijk. It's been a nightmare. If anyone is wondering how I'm doing this weekend... I'm living in a damn nightmare, and there's no waking up from it.

No. 9 - The List: Top 10 Leo DiCaprio movies ...

After doing a Denzel Washington Top 10 a week ago, I thought I'd stay in the movie wheelhouse and tackle a catalog I once was lukewarm about; now I’m a major fan.

Rewatchability played a big role in the rankings. For instance, Titanic might feel a tad low, but at the end of the day, I'd rather re-watch The Wolf of Wall Street a little more.

10. Revolutionary Road
9. Django Unchained
8. Catch Me If You Can
7. The Aviator
6. Titanic
5. The Wolf of Wall Street
4. Inception
3. The Departed
2. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
1. Gangs of New York

No. 10 - And Finally ...

Came close to a turkey vulture this weekend while walking around the neighborhood, as it was eating something near the sidewalk. I had the following thoughts and learned the following thing via the Internet..

a. Do other birds look at the turkey vulture and judge it for being so beastly looking?

b. Why do I only see turkey vultures while eating roadkill? Why doesn't it ever hang out on telephone wires around town? If they wanted to take over an area, do they just show up and the other birds get the hell out of the way because of their size and ugliness?

c. How would a suburb deal with hundreds of turkey vultures taking over like a pack of grackles? Imagine walking on a street and being surrounded by them. It doesn't seem like it would be a sightseeing thing... like... say.... a bat.

d. Did you know that a young turkey vulture will defend itself in a nest by throwing up on an intruder? Well, now you do.

View attachment 635
Nice read @Ketchum.
Wide eyed after seeing that throw - good heavens he's strong.
Nice photo of @TheAssquatch !
 
@Ketchum my neighborhood in atlanta has recently become home to about 100 Turkey vultures. They sit on top of 1-2 house at a time. We’ve been told the best way to get rid of them (besides shooting them which was my preference) is loud noises - they hate them
We have a bunch that hang out in the greenbelt next to the street here in Lakeway.
For a while they perched on top of a neighbor's chimney. Bet that smelled good when he fired it up.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Ketchum
We have a bunch that hang out in the greenbelt next to the street here in Lakeway.
For a while they perched on top of a neighbor's chimney. Bet that smelled good when he fired it up.
Sounds like an awesome greenbelt for bird watching!
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaulieD
I'm not sure that you4 2 +2 = 4.
If that is your response, I am not sure you read the write-up @Alex Dunlap did on Connor Robertson. Alex clearly thought the difference between Banks and Robertson was minimal and your ranking was off. Clearly Alex would be just as pleased with Robertson as Banks. I understand your comment about late risers, but this is someone your own expert has said is vastly underrated by you and you don't even address it. This isn't someone coming out of the shadows that hasn't been evaluated or offered.
 
If that is your response, I am not sure you read the write-up @Alex Dunlap did on Connor Robertson. Alex clearly thought the difference between Banks and Robertson was minimal and your ranking was off. Clearly Alex would be just as pleased with Robertson as Banks. I understand your comment about late risers, but this is someone your own expert has said is vastly underrated by you and you don't even address it. This isn't someone coming out of the shadows that hasn't been evaluated or offered.
a. Alex did the report after the latest rankings updates.

b. I have an off-field concern with Robertson.

c. He still doesn't rank as highly as the others IMO.
 
ee0e3a40b744e2eebc3b4d949eaa9055x.jpg
Texas coach Steve Sarkisian has it cooking in recruiting for the Longhorns in his first season, which isn't surprising when you consider that I predicted he would sign a top five class in 2022.

Still, I feel like we need to take a moment and show some appreciation for this staff's ability to create momentum almost out of thin air upon their arrival. Both Charlie Strong and Tom Herman had excellent rankings in their collective first recruiting class, but it took 5-6 months for both to find serious footing and results.

Sarkisian and Co. have been able to do it in 5-6 weeks, which has been critical when you realize how many top 2022 prospects in Texas have already started making decisions.

If you take a look at my recent Lone Star Recruiting Top 100 List, you'll find that three of the top five, five of the top nine and 12 of the top 22 prospects in the state have already made decisions. That's 55 percent.

Ready or not, the elite of the elite are making decisions early in Sarkisian's tenure.

To their credit, Sarkisian's staff have been more than ready.

No. 2 - The top remaining in-state options...

This list will evolve over the next 11 months, and there will be a few newcomers making breakthroughs in the rankings, especially in a COVID-dominated recruiting world, but with every passing year, it is stunning to see so many of the top names in the debut of each set of rankings end up near the top when the rankings are finished two years later.

With that in mind, here's a look at the top 15 remaining uncommitted prospects in the state by position. (LSR ranking in parenthesis)

* Players in bold have been offered or re-offered by the Texas staff

Quarterbacks

(1) Cade Klubnik (Austin Westlake)


(26) Alex Orji (Sachse)

Running Backs

(18) Jamarion Miller (Tyler Legacy)

(23) Tavorus Jones (El Paso Burges)

Wide Receivers


None

Tight Ends

None

Offensive Linemen

(6) Kam Dewberry (Humble Atascocita)

(10 Devon Campbell (Arlington Bowie)

(11) Kelvin Banks (Houston Summer Creek)

(25) Neto Umeozulu (Allen)

Defensive Linemen

(7) Omari Abor (Duncanville)

(24) Jaray Bledsoe (Bremond)

(27) Ernest Cooper (Arlington Martin)

Linebackers

(14) Harold Perkins (Cypress Park)

Defensive Backs

(2) Denver Harris (North Shore)

(15) Bryce Anderson (Beaumont Westbrook)

Athletes

(19) Brenen Thompson (Spearman)

No. 3 - Some impressions on the top remaining prospects ...


* Those four offensive line prospects are pretty much everything in this class considering what happened a year ago. Of course, the Longhorns could hit on an out-of-state guy or two, and there's always a chance that a player emerges from the shadows of the early rankings and becomes a Top 15-25 level prospect, but Banks, Campbell, Dewberry and Umeozulu (ranked in any order you want) are at the core of what this 2022 class will need in order to become a true success.

* Not including Klubnik, the skill position group is thin in impact prospects. The highest-rated skill player remaining (running backs/wide receivers/tight ends) is Miller at No. 18. The importance of the Jaydon "Don't Call Him Alfred" Blue and Evan Stewart commitments cannot be overstated, as they were the last two remaining offensive skill prospects remaining from the five-star and high four-star tiers of the rankings; Brenen Thompson could end up in that area, while technically being recruited as an athlete by a lot of schools.

* The importance of Jason Llewellyn as a prospect is probably impacted by his profile and the scarcity of players at his position. Still, the Longhorns are loaded at the wide receiver position, so if there was ever a year where they could survive a lack of tight end prospects, it's in 2022. Look for Jeff Banks to stay on Llewellyn, while looking for an out-of-state guy to poach; most of the tight ends in Texas look like developmental projects with somewhat limited upside.

* Barring a flip of Bear Alexander or Malick Sylla, the Longhorns aren’t going to fill their needs along the defensive line from the Lone Star State alone. Only Duncanville's Abor remains as an elite option.

* Historically, the value of linebackers is suspect, to say the least, but Perkins is clearly the apple of everyone's eye at his position.

* Denver Harris and Bryce Anderson are in the discussion for best remaining prospects, but there's a pile of defensive backs right outside of the top 25 that does give this position more depth than the top 15 might suggest. Aledo's Bryan Allen, Katy's Bobby Taylor, Plano John Paul's Terrance Brooks and Garland's Chace Biddle would all be in the next 10. I personally view Harris and Alexander on different, higher tiers than the others.

No. 4 - Four weekend thoughts on Maalik Murphy ...

1. While I have Klubnik and Quinn Ewers ranked as five-star quarterback prospects, I'm not sure that either are in the same league as Murphy when it comes to his physical profile and ability to throw the football on an absolute line.

Take a look at this freaking throw and its trajectory. For all of Ewers’ accuracy (and he could end up being the most accurate prospect the state has produced in a decade), he doesn't quite throw the ball consistently like this.



2. I'm really having a hard time coming up with a name for a former Longhorn that Murphy reminds me off. Maybe Chris Simms to a degree, but I think Murphy throws the intermediate and deep intermediate ball better than Simms did at the same age.

3. Watching him throw in 7-on-7 feels like watching an elite power hitter take batting practice.

4. He's got the Hook'em down correctly. This is important.

maalik-murphy-jpg.630


No. 5 - About 2022 Defensive Back Recruiting ...

If you inspect the plan for the Texas defensive backfield, you'll find that the commitment of Landon Hullaby to Oregon won’t impact the recruiting class much. Consider:

a. The Longhorns will probably take between 4-6 defensive backs, depending on the hit rate at the top of their board. The betting favorite would probably be five defensive backs, but if Texas gets everyone, they'd probably make room for a sixth difference maker. Four feels on the light side and might mean a commitment peeled off, or Texas missed on more players than anticipated.

b. With Port Arthur Memorial's Jaylon Guilbeau already committed, you'd have to think that the staff has two spots reserved for Bryce Anderson and Denver Harris.

c. A commitment by Hullaby would have left the program with less positional versatility in its remaining offers, considering Texas has offered 22 higher-rated players at the position thus far in the 2022 class. Hullaby is a really good prospect, but there's a chance that spot will be filled with a prospect with a higher/more valuable profile.

d. The reality of there being fewer spots available might create some urgency on those final spots in the remaining field of offers.

No. 6 - Uh oh ...

If there's one thing you can say with 100-percent certainty about long-time followers of the Texas men's basketball program, we can spot a late-season collapse coming a mile away.

The program has shown a repeated ability to steal a sad ending from the jaws of a successful season.

So, when the team's inconsistent form turned into a disaster against West Virginia that included an embarrassing argument between two upperclassmen/leaders of the team and blowing a 19-point lead, well.... you'll have to excuse us when we all run into the nearest room and yell, "FIIIIRRRRRREEEEEE!!!!!!!"

For most of this season, I have firmly believed that Texas would make a run in the NCAA Tournament for the first time in a decade, but this was a collapse.

The way this team fumbled and bumbled its way through the final 10 minutes was not the stuff of future NCAA Tournament success, and typically those types of runs come from a team starting to play its best basketball right about now. You won't find many college backcourts with as much experience as the trio of Matt Coleman, Andrew Jones and Courtney Ramey, which is why I've been so confident in this group in an early NCAA Tournament setting, but the decision-making and execution from this trio on Saturday was u-g-l-y.

Jones had a poor game that featured a ton of turnovers (6) and missed shots (12), several of which inexplicably felt like mistimed heat checks. Ramey was in NBA Jam "Fire Mode" when he was suckered into committing his fifth foul at a time when the team couldn't afford to lose him. Meanwhile, Coleman ruined a great shooting night when he missed the front end of a 1-and-1 that could have allowed Texas to tie the game at 84-84 with less than 10 seconds left.

Everyone following the program is preparing for the worst because it’s what we have been conditioned to expect.

It's not that this team can't make a run; it would just be insanity to expect different results and not the same thing over and over again.

No. 7 – BUY or SELL …


(Buy) I don't buy it with much confidence, though.


(Sell) I'm more worried about the closing out of the game on Saturday than the dust-up on the sidelines. It was embarrassing, but this team hasn't been playing its best basketball for a while now.


(Sell) Is this what people are saying? I think there's more excitement going down on the offensive side of the ball at the moment, which is understandable, but I don't expect this class to be dominated by its offensive prospects alone. I didn't view the Hullaby commitment as anything other than an opportunity.


(Buy) He's more game-ready right now.


(Buy) Yes and yes.


(Buy) I don't like it.


(Sell) I think common sense indicates there's a good chance of that.


(Buy) The portal will be busy.


(Buy) No question.


(Sell) I believe they are equal-sized pieces of the puzzle.


(Sell) Die Hard isn't a Christmas movie, but it is the superior movie.


(Buy) You misspelled decades.

No. 8 - Scattershooting on the world of sports...

... It sucks that the career of Charli Collier likely won't end with a better supporting cast; Vic Schaefer will eventually bring in that kind of talent.

... Tanking all of those seasons to have a chance to see Joel Embiid have a 50-piece to go along with 17 rebounds on Friday night in the middle of a potential MVP season was worth it.

... This will never get old.


... I don't get the "Carson Wentz makes the Colts a Super Bowl threat" talk at all.

... I read a mock draft on Sunday and I can honestly say that I'm not yet in draft-mode at all.

... Can't say I was surprised to see that Derrick Lewis knocked someone out this weekend. Can't say I know what Curtis Blaydes was thinking in terms of his approach.

... Novak Djokovic won No. 18 this weekend. Here's hoping he doesn't get to No. 20. Signed, a Nadal homer.

... It feels like the era of Naomi Osaka is truly upon us.

.... I feel like I'm reliving the 1999 season for the Dallas Cowboys as a Liverpool FC fan, with the injury fallout from losing Michel Irvin looking similar to what has happened since the injury to Virgil Van Dijk. It's been a nightmare. If anyone is wondering how I'm doing this weekend... I'm living in a damn nightmare, and there's no waking up from it.

No. 9 - The List: Top 10 Leo DiCaprio movies ...

After doing a Denzel Washington Top 10 a week ago, I thought I'd stay in the movie wheelhouse and tackle a catalog I once was lukewarm about; now I’m a major fan.

Rewatchability played a big role in the rankings. For instance, Titanic might feel a tad low, but at the end of the day, I'd rather re-watch The Wolf of Wall Street a little more.

10. Revolutionary Road
9. Django Unchained
8. Catch Me If You Can
7. The Aviator
6. Titanic
5. The Wolf of Wall Street
4. Inception
3. The Departed
2. Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
1. Gangs of New York

No. 10 - And Finally ...

Came close to a turkey vulture this weekend while walking around the neighborhood, as it was eating something near the sidewalk. I had the following thoughts and learned the following thing via the Internet..

a. Do other birds look at the turkey vulture and judge it for being so beastly looking?

b. Why do I only see turkey vultures while eating roadkill? Why doesn't it ever hang out on telephone wires around town? If they wanted to take over an area, do they just show up and the other birds get the hell out of the way because of their size and ugliness?

c. How would a suburb deal with hundreds of turkey vultures taking over like a pack of grackles? Imagine walking on a street and being surrounded by them. It doesn't seem like it would be a sightseeing thing... like... say.... a bat.

d. Did you know that a young turkey vulture will defend itself in a nest by throwing up on an intruder? Well, now you do.

View attachment 635
We may be missing out on a great food source, I wonder if you fed out a vulture out on grain it would taste like turkey, You game?
 
a. Alex did the report after the latest rankings updates.

b. I have an off-field concern with Robertson.

c. He still doesn't rank as highly as the others IMO.
I understand Alex did his report after your LSR rankings, but before yesterday. I don't know about the off-field concern. You are writing a column for the same site that Alex does and you even acknowledge that Alex's report came after the rankings, but you fail to even acknowledge it. Clearly Alex would argue that Robertson belongs in your top 25.
 
I understand Alex did his report after your LSR rankings, but before yesterday. I don't know about the off-field concern. You are writing a column for the same site that Alex does and you even acknowledge that Alex's report came after the rankings, but you fail to even acknowledge it. Clearly Alex would argue that Robertson belongs in your top 25.
a. The off-field concern hasn't really been talked about. I'm acknowledging it now.

b. I disagree with Alex.

c. I'm not sure why I would acknowledge Alex's report when it has nothing to do with my own list of current rankings.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaulieD
@Ketchum
Not that you have him ranked low but why is Thompson not ranked higher? With the truly elite track times I was expecting to see a track guy playing football but he is a football player with track speed. Only knocks I can think of (neither is really bad just could be better) is a common size and his cuts are not Reggie Bush smooth (no one is).
 
@Ketchum
Not that you have him ranked low but why is Thompson not ranked higher? With the truly elite track times I was expecting to see a track guy playing football but he is a football player with track speed. Only knocks I can think of (neither is really bad just could be better) is a common size and his cuts are not Reggie Bush smooth (no one is).
I was having this exact conversation in my head about his ranking this weekend when I was thinking about the industry's ranking of Marquise Goodwin.

I think you're correct. It'll be an oversight that almost certainly gets corrected in the next rankings update. He has a literal elite of the elite hitting tool (if we were to use a baseball metaphor) and that by itself should be viewed as an elite quality.

Good call. Your brain is working well. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaulieD
If that is your response, I am not sure you read the write-up @Alex Dunlap did on Connor Robertson. Alex clearly thought the difference between Banks and Robertson was minimal and your ranking was off. Clearly Alex would be just as pleased with Robertson as Banks. I understand your comment about late risers, but this is someone your own expert has said is vastly underrated by you and you don't even address it. This isn't someone coming out of the shadows that hasn't been evaluated or offered.

I didn’t necessarily say Robertson is as good, I said I don’t think the disparity is that large. I did say I think Neto Oneozulu is basically as good as Banks but with a few things to clean up
 
I didn’t necessarily say Robertson is as good, I said I don’t think the disparity is that large. I did say I think Neto Oneozulu is basically as good as Banks but with a few things to clean up
And on this front, Neto will move into the top 15 in the next update.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alex Dunlap
Ketch, why is it that, CONSISTENTLY, every time a player we are after goes ahead and commits to another school (insert Hullaby) the talk then goes to “well, he wasn’t really that good”? I’m asking this becaus, if Hullaby would have committed to Texas, the mods would be extolling the virtues of how great a player he is, it happens every time. Just wondering why?
 
  • Like
Reactions: bradford345
Ketch, why is it that, CONSISTENTLY, every time a player we are after goes ahead and commits to another school (insert Hullaby) the talk then goes to “well, he wasn’t really that good”? I’m asking this becaus, if Hullaby would have committed to Texas, the mods would be extolling the virtues of how great a player he is, it happens every time. Just wondering why?
a. name another time this has happened.

b. I have him rated as a high three star prospect and described him as a special teams player and a 2-3 project on the field with questions about his ability to cover.

There is far less evidence of what you are suggesting takes place than you believe.
 
@samthehorn I'm old enough to remember when this board lost its shit because I called Malick Sylla's commitment to A&M a "huge get".
 
@Ketchum

I agree and I'm super impressed with what Sark and staff have been able to do with recruiting momentum so quickly

Its exactly what was needed - but counting it as a layup that was easy to achieve in the current situation is being taken for granted
 
  • Like
Reactions: PaulieD
@Ketchum

I agree and I'm super impressed with what Sark and staff have been able to do with recruiting momentum so quickly

Its exactly what was needed - but counting it as a layup that was easy to achieve in the current situation is being taken for granted
totally agree.
 
I mean... the backcourt IS good.
I disagree. But maybe it’s a definition of what we think is “good”. If by good you mean “they can make it to the tourney”, then sure they are good. My definition of good is sweet 16/top 10 in the country. And we aren’t close to that. Shot selection, decision making and ability to control tempo are all lacking from all of them. At least at a high level and on a consistent basis.

the only chance a Shaka team has of having tourney success is if we get hot and shoot lights out a couple games.
 
I disagree. But maybe it’s a definition of what we think is “good”. If by good you mean “they can make it to the tourney”, then sure they are good. My definition of good is sweet 16/top 10 in the country. And we aren’t close to that. Shot selection, decision making and ability to control tempo are all lacking from all of them. At least at a high level and on a consistent basis.

the only chance a Shaka team has of having tourney success is if we get hot and shoot lights out a couple games.
My definition of good is that each of Coleman, Ramey and Jones is good. None are great, but I'd argue that all range between good and very good.
 
The Departed had the chance to be a great movie but the ending was so terrible it made the whole things shit.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: PaulieD
At some point, we have to acknowledge how much of a monster the movie is the history of film. Has to be in the top 10 somewhere.
I absolutely acknowledge the impact of that movie. However, you mentioned rewatchability playing a key role in the rankings. I actually tried rewatching it recently and it didn’t come close to the spectacle it was the first time I saw it, so that knocks it off the list.
 
ADVERTISEMENT