ADVERTISEMENT

Ketch's 10 Thoughts From the Weekend (The importance of Todd Orlando...)

I will apologize for not seeing greatness in Herman during a year when he was quite average after he displays elite of the elite greatness.

Deal.;)

Technically that would be apologizing for being right. That's like apologizing for misevaluating a 2 star that becomes great. the original eval was right based on evidence presented if greatness wasn't evident in any capacity.

somewhat unrelated question: I treat star rankings as a starting point in the race to being all americans/draft picks. They don't rule out anyone's chances but some start off closer to the finish and have a stronger chance to make it. too many people read stars as a definitive, IMO. is that fair?
 
Technically that would be apologizing for being right. That's like apologizing for misevaluating a 2 star that becomes great. the original eval was right based on evidence presented if greatness wasn't evident in any capacity.

somewhat unrelated question: I treat star rankings as a starting point in the race to being all americans/draft picks. They don't rule out anyone's chances but some start off closer to the finish and have a stronger chance to make it. too many people read stars as a definitive, IMO. is that fair?
a. I don't think that's quite the same thing. It would be an admission of being wrong, regardless of the phrasing.

b. Absolutely, fair.
 
a. I don't think that's quite the same thing. It would be an admission of being wrong, regardless of the phrasing.

b. Absolutely, fair.

I see what you're saying, but my point was just that there's nothing that can really fault you for the stance with all evidence as it stands now. If evidence changes that doesn't devalue the original stance because that evidence didn't exist when the point was made.
 
I am sorry I don't get The Shape of Water love.

It's a 1950's monster movie shot in a French art house style. What am I missing?

I don't know that youre missing anything... these are subjective.

It was a creative story, beautifully shot and incredible well acted.. but those are opinions. I was actually surprised I liked it so much.

Michael Shannon is a wonderful antagonist.
 
By the end of the season special teams was fine. The only problem we had was a kicker who he was pressed to find when he got the job here. I be Rowland is decent next year and allows Dicker to come along at the right pace. We did not allow a punt or kickoff return for a TD, and by the bowl game coverage looked solid.

I think this is true, as he struggled to get a good feel for the team this year on offense. Probably one of the reasons he is getting more involved. If it doesn't improve year two we should worry. That being said, players at certain positions need to step up and be reliable. I did not see anyone kill it once they were given a chance. DY probably the best example. Certainly better than Porter but not some elite talent that knows how to block on a blitz. Know what I mean...

Identity often comes from your QB and playing to their strengths. QB is so critical, as is rhythm and timing between QB, WR core and OC. They need to develop that in the off-season. It did not materialize quickly enough this year.

He did at times, and it was ugly. Not sure what you were watching, but getting stuffed for losses on first down is not a recipe for success.

I guess. This comes up every year, and it happens to everyone. I would argue Bama has a talent advantage over Auburn as well, etc etc etc. We almost beat USC, who at this point has a talent advantage. As does OU, OSU, TCU and most of the other teams that beat us. Expect that to change.

That is on the coaches and players. Players have the ultimate responsibility. I am not sure Drayton forgot how to coach RB, or Melinger who made lemonade out of lemons at UH, have forgotten how to coach. This was a transition year, and the pups like RHM and LJH and TC better get their shit together and take the next step cause others are coming.

This team was vastly better in many ways than the teams CS coached, and while they struggled they fought in every game. Year two should see us get to 8-9 wins and those hand-wringing over the oline need to chill out. Players on their way and improvements will be made. TC and DY need to take over at RB, and our WR need to step up. I don't blame the coaches for their softness...and they are soft.
I'll just say that I'm still hopeful that Herman will get things turned around, but all of the problems we saw this year can't simply be put on the players. It's his staff's job to get them ready to play and to put them in the best position to succeed. Using the correct running backs and being more persistent with the running game was something that could have made a difference in some of the early games we lost. This was very obvious to me and many others as it was happening.
 
My last comment on this. After 2017, we know TH is an elite recruiter and there’s no reason to think that won’t continue which means we have elite talent within a couple more years. We also know Orlando is an elite DC. Finally, we know TH’s body of work demonstrates that he knows what he’s doing on O. Bottom line, I think it’s more likely than not that he wins a NC at UT. Of course, JMO.
 
I'll just say that I'm still hopeful that Herman will get things turned around, but all of the problems we saw this year can't simply be put on the players. It's his staff's job to get them ready to play and to put them in the best position to succeed. Using the correct running backs and being more persistent with the running game was something that could have made a difference in some of the early games we lost. This was very obvious to me and many others as it was happening.

Agreed. He started with Warren, who checked out and flat out sucked. Now, oline is an issue and scheme was a problem but clearly attitude was as well. He gone. Certainly persistence in the run game needs to be better. Interestingly, our most successful RB plays in the bowl game were wheel routes.

I am simply pointing out that there is joint responsibility for success that involves coaches and players. While Herman needs to improve the offense, the offensive players also need to work to improve. Timing needs to be a non-stop effort during the summer and whoever our QB is needs to lead those practices. Sam or Shane need to get our WR together and vow not to suck next year and work. That will go a long way towards success in 2018.
 
I'm hearing it is quite possible.
I am concerned that as long as Tim Beck is present and holds the title of "Play Caller", that Tom Herman will be tempted to have Tim call plays. I will be more comfortable if something more official is announced. But, I am not holding my breath.
 
I don't see how anyone could suggest they saw something this year that makes them certain a freaking national title is assured in his tenure.
Tom Herman's decision to appoint Tim Beck as the OC certainly has me agreeing with Ketch.
 
Nice article Ketch.

I think the "sense of urgency" to get the offense straightened out is just the fact that that is a prerequisite for winning at a high level which we so desperately want/need to have happen ... not to do it while Orlando is still here to make the D work at the same time. I love me some Todd Orlando, but no coach (not named Royal, Saban, Meyer, Belicheck etc.) should be considered that irreplaceable.

Basketball ... Shaka will not need seat warmers on his car for those cold winter days if we miss the dance this year. And like you, I think that is a greater than 50% chance that happens now.
 
Unfortunately, 2017 did happen...
  • Continued horrible special teams (point of emphasis prior to season)
  • Questionable personnel management decisions
  • Questionable in-game decision making at times
  • Stubbornness with OC/Play Calling situation
  • Lack of identity on offense
  • Failure to commit to the running game
  • Losses in 2 games where they had a significant talent advantage.
  • Regression/no improvement in individual skill level at OL, WR and QB.
It's true that there was improvement in a number of areas (mainly associated with the defense), but Herman is gonna have to step up his game in order for me to view this as a well coached team. All of the problems this team encountered can't be attributed to OL injuries. Orlando lost a sh$tload of key defensive players prior to the bowl game, yet we saw no drop-off in his unit's performance.

Much of this is spot on. Some could be quibbled with, but the first item is puzzling to me.
If I attempt to break down special teams, I get:
  • Punts - I'm pretty sure we were the best in college football (or all football for that matter).
  • Punt returns. - Solid. A few stupid mistakes, but we are talking about personal decisions of 18 to 21 year old men.
  • Kickoffs - Solid. More than not went into the endzone for a touchback.
  • Kickoff returns - Solid. I didn't see much of an issue here.
  • Kickoff and Punt return protection - pretty good as an average for the year.
  • So that leaves Field Goal kicking - That sucked, but that was a function of not having a kicker. CTH did attempt to correct this last offseason. It appears he just missed on Rowland (although he got a very good Kickoff guy).
I just can't see how anyone would slam the coaching staff for "Continued horrible special teams". They probably accounted for two or more wins this season.
 
  • Like
Reactions: llanojohn
My last comment on this. After 2017, we know TH is an elite recruiter and there’s no reason to think that won’t continue which means we have elite talent within a couple more years. We also know Orlando is an elite DC. Finally, we know TH’s body of work demonstrates that he knows what he’s doing on O. Bottom line, I think it’s more likely than not that he wins a NC at UT. Of course, JMO.
This is what people said about Charlie after a 6-7 first season.
 

Todd Orlando is the most valuable property that Tom Herman's football program holds.

Not the fancy new lockers. Not the support staff. Not the other eight assistant coaches combined.

It's Orlando.

Way back in November of 2016, I had a conversation with one of the most influential people in the entire University of Texas universe about the subject of Tom Herman potentially being the next Texas head coach in the event that Charlie Strong wasn't retained.

The theory on the attractiveness of a Herman hire was this:

a. The Texas offense was a disaster. By bringing in Herman, the thought was that Texas would have one of the nation's top offensive masterminds pulling the strings on that side of the ball.

b. If Herman was able to hold up his end of the bargain, an elite defensive coordinator would need to be paired with him.

The thinking was that those two things added together would translate to championships and it's pretty much the foundation of the decision to hire Herman.

With a fat raise on the way this off-season for his work and increased value on the open market, the Longhorns have created a universe for their top asset that will allow him to pull a Kirby Smart if he wants to - wait until the right head coaching job opens up and don't sweat the first job that opens up because it's kind of a decent opportunity.

Orlando turns 46 at some point this year and you know he'll want to be a head coach at some point if he can. It's the obvious next step in his evolution and I'm sure he'd prefer it happen sooner than later, but if you can make close to $2 million per year while waiting for a quality opportunity and not just an opportunity, well ... that's a hell of a consolation prize to massage any hurting lustful ambition.

While it's possible Orlando will stay in Austin for the next decade, perhaps earning as much as $20 million along the way, the smart money likely has him here in town for a season or two.

From my vantage point, it puts the pressure to Herman to step up the offense's game because the window he has with this potentially special coordinator gets smaller with every day that passes. The last thing this program can afford to have happen is to witness the offense finally get to where it needs to be at the exact moment as its ace defensive leader leaves town.

You can say that Herman can just go out and hire the best defensive coordinator in the country, but it's not always as easy as that. Just ask Texas A&M.

There's a very serendipitous thing about these things. Vince Lombardi had magic in a bottle in Green Bay and couldn't replicate it in Washington. Jimmy Johnson was a coaching god in Dallas and a mere mortal in Miami. Hell, look no further than the Manny Diaz experiment ... from budding rock star to fired in-season to almost remade again.

Timing and circumstances matter.

What Texas has in Orlando is lightening in a bottle, and all the money and ambition in the world can't automatically buy that.

So, when you have it, you better take advantage of it.

That's one of Herman's challenges in the next two years ... get all of the parts in this program working together at an elite-level in a way that allows you to take advantage of the serendipity. Texas has pulled this off before, but the "head-coaching-in-waiting" card isn't one that can be played in this instance.

The moment is now. It must be so.

No. 2 – Just for the record ...

My all-time Texas defensive coordinator rankings for the last quarter-century look like this.

1. Greg Robinson
2. Will Muschamp
3. Todd Orlando
4. Gene Chizik
5. Bull Reese

The work Robinson did with the 2004 and 2013 defenses was as good as any work any coach has ever done in this town. I think Orlando has a chance to end up in the No. 1 spot because I actually think he's a better coordinator than Muschamp, but he has to coach in some big games first.

No. 3 – Attaboy, Burnt Orange Daddy Warbucks ...

It's easy to take shots at the Texas administration during a stretch of time when the football program is in the worst rut in the history of the program, but I'm going to acknowledge a point that has been lost in the last decade or so.

For all of the failures in the program, committing resources on assistant coaches has never been one.

When Mack Brown needed a game-changer following the 2007 season, Texas went out and spent big bucks to bring Muschamp in. When the wheels were spinning in mud in the final years of Mack's regime, he had all the support he needed to go get whomever it was he needed to get. Hell, it was thought to be impossible to pull Bryan Harsin from Boise, but money talks and everything else walks, and Texas ponied up the money needed to pull it off.

When Charlie Strong requested silly sums for Vance Bedford and Shawn Watson, not one person blinked because no one wanted to ever hear that Strong didn't have the money to hire the staff he wanted.

When Herman needed $1.7 million this week just to make sure nothing happened with Orlando, he received instant backing.

The return on investment has often lacked significantly, but the investment is always there.

No. 4 – The elephant in the room ...
talk-about-the-white-elephant-in-the-room.png




You want to know the cold, hard truth about Kendal Briles?

He's been far more protected in the last two years by a flunking system and a good ol’ boy network that refuses to demand answers than any of the victims in the Baylor Rape Scandal ever were.

The purpose of the Pepper Hamilton verbal report was to protect the bad guys, of which there were many, out of pure self-interest. Transparency and accountability were never a goal and along the way, it has allowed almost everyone who WAS involved in what happened a clean getaway.

Multiple coaches and football staff members were involved in the cover-up of the Baylor scandal according to the Pepper Hamilton report. We not only know that, we know that Baylor protected them throughout the 2016 season by keeping them on staff ... because football. When you have men in a position of power and all they care about is winning football, what you come away with is a situation where zero accountability is demanded for really important things.

What on earth has Kendal Briles done in the last two years that would suggest he deserves the benefit of the doubt? Maybe Major Applewhite would like to give that question a go.

Just name one thing.

There's not one. Like his daddy before him, Kendal Briles is counting on our attention span being short enough that a gnat would blush to pave the path for him.

The truth is that none deserve the benefit of the doubt, least of which someone who worked shoulder to shoulder with Art for years, has been named in at least one lawsuit and hasn't so much as once denounced or owned an ounce of accountability for what happened in public fashion.

You're telling me that a guy seemingly covered with 2,000 pounds of dirt gets an unquestioned second chance without ever truly being forced to give up his first chance? Before he has to so much as answer a single question about his role? Before we know how deep his role was? Before it's clear that he needs to be on a football field over a jail cell?

G-O-O-D O-L B-O-Y N-E-T-W-O-R-K.

Upon learning of all the ways the system failed so many victims in Waco, we're failing them again by essentially allowing for the shady tactics used by Baylor to stand as a shield for the monsters and the final silenced word on the matter. As a society, we talk a good game, but we practice it like crap.

Imagine a world, where a coach that previously should have been fired for having sexual relations with a student trainer but wasn't, is given the latitude just a few years later to personally vouch for a friend of his who would be Evil Pig-Pen if placed in a Peanuts remake of the Baylor Rape Scandal?

Actually, you don't have to imagine a thing. Just open your eyes.


No. 5 – Five thoughts on the Army All-American Bowl ...

a. I can see Caden Sterns pushing Brandon Jones and every other safety on the roster for playing time if the junior-to-be doesn't start elevating his game because Sterns is the kind of player you almost have to have on the field and if he's not on the field, there better a bad mamma jamma in front of him doing bad mamma jamma things.

b. Jaylen Waddle is going to be hell on wheels at the next level. If that guy picks an offense that schemes for players with his skill set, he's going to be a college star. The only thing keeping him from being a five-star is the lack of five-star measurables, but the dude has five-star game.

c. Anthony Cook isn't a five-star. He was the third best UT DB signing at the game all week. Adjust some expectations.

d. I'm buying Jalen Green stock.

e. Junior Angilau needs a redshirt year unless he's developed at an elite level by an elite coach. I'm not saying my opinion can't be changed, I'm just saying he looked like the 95 percent of high school linemen that aren't quite ready for prime time when they arrive on a college campus.

No. 6 – The only men's basketball thought I have this weekend ...

Get better, Andrew Jones.

I wrote a bunch of stuff about the loss in Waco this weekend and deleted all of it when I found myself wondering whether this team has a chance without Jones.

As if that remotely matters more than his health and if he's been struggling to feel right for the last few weeks, I'm not sure we even need to bother with basketball discussion that involves him until he's feeling much better.

No. 7 – Ho-hum …

The Lady Longhorns handled some business on Sunday afternoon in Manhattan and while they have games against TCU and Kansas looming this week, it's pretty impossible to ignore what's slated a week from now.

Monday, January 15th - No. 1 UConn is coming to town.

My popcorn is already popping.

No. 8 – Buy or Sell …
buy_sell.jpg


BUY or SELL: Tom Herman's 10th assistant will be a home run hire?

(Sell) A true home run hire is a household name that usually don't even exist in reality. Barring the addition of a star offensive coordinator that bumps Tim Beck out of the program, I'm not sure that many would call whatever Herman does an actual home run. He's probably going to hire a position coach of some variety and most of those don't bring jaw-dropping resumes that you could dare label a home run.

BUY or SELL: Tom Herman should concern himself with Lincoln Riley, as opposed to Jimbo Fisher?

(Sell) The head coach at The University of Texas must be able to concern himself with both at all times because he doesn't live in an "either/or" kind of world.

BUY or SELL: After one year of seeing Tom Herman in action; he wins a National Championship at Texas?

(Sell) This question kind of mystifies me.

BUY or SELL: In the aftermath of the Texas Bowl, Tom Herman now knows with certainty that he needs a new offensive play caller?

(Buy) Given that he called plays in the bowl game, but only after practicing in bowl workouts, I'd say he definitely understands the play-calling needs in the aftermath of the bowl game.

BUY or SELL: The 10th assistant is an offensive line coach?

(Buy) I think it's much, much more likely than a quarterback/play-calling OC. I'm starting to believe that we'll see more of Lincoln Riley in Tom Herman next year.

BUY or SELL: Tom Herman redshirts both freshman QBs next year?

(Sell) I've already gone on the record that I believe one of the two freshmen will be the No .2 by October.

BUY or SELL: It doesn’t matter who are the top two quarterbacks going into next season. They will be compared to Applewhite and Simms by Ketchum?

(Buy) Ok, I'm sure at some point it'll be inevitable that the Applewhite/Simms reference is cited, but do I have a reputation for dragging that situation up that I don't know about? For the record, I looked at the archives of this column and the last time the Applewhite/Simms situation was specifically referenced was 11 months ago.

BUY or SELL: Elko is another home run hire by the Aggies?

(Sell) Stand-up double. Really strong hire, but not one that will move meters.

BUY or SELL: Baker Mayfield is to Lincoln Riley what Johnny Manziel was to Kevin Sumlin?

(Buy) Very, very possible. I mean ... Mayfield is the best player in the history of the program according to a lot of Sooners. We'll know more about Riley in 2018 than we ever learned in 2017.

BUY or SELL: Texas has a future NFL draft pick competing for its starting QB position this fall?

(Sell) No way I'm walking out on that limb at this point with zero evidence that this exists.

BUY or SELL: We make March Madness?

(Sell) It can't be done without Andrew Jones on the floor leading the way and he's not currently on the floor leading the way. I've been an optimist all season, but my optimism is slipping.

BUY or SELL: Shaka?

(Buy) Pure confirmation bias on my part. I can't defend his first three years very strongly, but I still believe in him. Next year will be a do-or-die season for him and I think it all starts to come together.

No. 9 – Eternal Randomness of the Spotty Sports Mind …

... Prediction: Alabama 24 Georgia 13

... The wildcard round of the NFL playoffs was about as entertaining as the college football bowl season leading up to the playoffs for about 10 hours... and then Carolina/New Orleans happened. What. A. Game.

... Drew Brees actually had a "No, Danny, no!" moment late in the fourth quarter. I'm not sure I would have believed it if I hadn't seen it.

... Derrick Johnson deserves better than to have played his entire career in Kansas City with quarterbacking play that can't get the team out of the Wildcard round.

... Speaking of Derrick Johnson...


... The Falcons look like a team capable of getting back to the Super Bowl.

... I think the possible handshake between Antonio Conte/Jose Mourinho the next time United and Chelsea play will be more highly anticipated than the Super Bowl.

... I couldn't have been alone in enjoying Nottingham Forest "dominate" Arsenal on Sunday.

... I wish nothing but the best for Philippe Coutinho, but I would have liked to have seen him end his tenure with a touch more class, with actions that didn't include putting in a transfer request the day before the season started or claiming two injuries just as two transfer windows opened or letting his entourage play games with the media for almost a year. At the end of the day, he quit on his team in the middle of the season and that truth won't go away quickly.

... Oh captain, my future captain.


No. 9B – Updated Oscar rankings …
mudbound.jpg


Had a chance to catch "Mudbound" this week while I was battling a nasty 24-hour flu of some kind and while the Netflix original isn't a feel-good movie for the family, it's one hell of a well-acted movie.

Any and all acting accolades in the coming weeks from the cast will be well-earned.

My updated Oscars rankings.

(Still need to see: All the Money in the World, Call Me By Your Name, Darkest Hour, Detroit, The Florida Project, I, Tonya, Phantom Thread, The Post and Roman J. Israel, Esq)

Best Picture

1. Lady Bird
2. The Shape of Water
3. Dunkirk
4. The Big Sick
5. Wind River
6. Mudbound
7. The Disaster Artist
8. Three Billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri
9. Get Out
10. Blake Runner 2049

Best Actor

1. James Franco (The Disaster Artist)
2. Adam Driver (The Last Jedi)
3. Daniel Kaluuya (Get Out)
4. Jeremy Renner (Wind River)
5. Kumail Nanjiani (The Big Sick)

Best Actress

1. Sally Hawkins (The Shape of Water)
2. Saoirse Ronan (Lady Bird)
3. Frances McDormand (Three Billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri)
4. Emma Stone (Battle of the Sexes)
5. Elizabeth Olson (Wind River)

Best Supporting Actor

1. Michael Shannon (The Shape of Water)
2. Sam Rockwell (Three Billboards outside Ebbing, Missouri)
3. Richard Jenkins (The Shape of Water)
4. Jason Mitchell (Mudbound)
5. Rob Morgan (Mudbound)

Best Supporting Actress

1. Laurie Metcalf (Lady Bird)
2. Holly Hunter (The Big Sick)
3. Carey Mulligan (Mudbound)
4. Mary J. Blige (Mudbound)
5. Octavia Spencer (The Shape of Water)

Best Director

1. The Shape of Water (Guillermo del Toro)
2. Greta Gerwig (Lady Bird)
3. Jordan Peele (Get Out)
4. Christopher Nolan (Dunkirk)
5. Denis Villeneuve (Blade Runner 2049)

No. 10 – And Finally …

I wanted to end things with a special thanks to the folks over at Covert Chevrolet/Ford in Hutto for being the latest partner to join our family at Orangebloods and the new official sponsor of 10TFTW.

They are Longhorns through and through, and I can't wait to make a full introduction later in the week.
Defense got better under Orlando,O got worse with Herman
 
As I said in the other thread, Briles Jr is far, far less responsible than Baylor’s AD for what happened at Baylor. The real outrage is this happened almost immediately after Baylor was forced to fire McCaw:

Ian-McCaw-Jerry-Falwell-Liberty-Athletics-secondary.jpg
what am I took understand with you new photo?
 
"Next year will be a do-or-die season for him and I think it all starts to come together."

pure baloney
 
Much of this is spot on. Some could be quibbled with, but the first item is puzzling to me.
If I attempt to break down special teams, I get:
  • Punts - I'm pretty sure we were the best in college football (or all football for that matter).
  • Punt returns. - Solid. A few stupid mistakes, but we are talking about personal decisions of 18 to 21 year old men.
  • Kickoffs - Solid. More than not went into the endzone for a touchback.
  • Kickoff returns - Solid. I didn't see much of an issue here.
  • Kickoff and Punt return protection - pretty good as an average for the year.
  • So that leaves Field Goal kicking - That sucked, but that was a function of not having a kicker. CTH did attempt to correct this last offseason. It appears he just missed on Rowland (although he got a very good Kickoff guy).
I just can't see how anyone would slam the coaching staff for "Continued horrible special teams". They probably accounted for two or more wins this season.
I guess my main concern was with the field goal unit and the decisions early in the season to forego some obvious punt and chip shot fg attempts. Also, the fact that our punt returner didn't seem to know when or how to correctly field the ball for much of the season. The punter was excellent, but as you stated, that had very little to do with the coaching staff; he was excellent last year too. I guess special teams as a whole were not "horrible", but they were definitely a dissapointment versus the expectations.
 
I guess my main concern was with the field goal unit and the decisions early in the season to forego some obvious punt and chip shot fg attempts. Also, the fact that our punt returner didn't seem to know when or how to correctly field the ball for much of the season. The punter was excellent, but as you stated, that had very little to do with the coaching staff; he was excellent last year too. I guess special teams as a whole were not "horrible", but they were definitely a dissapointment versus the expectations.

Ok. I'm with you. I just think the main train wreck was the field goal kicking. CTH surely didn't have confidence there, but I cant blame him.

I do think they worked on capitalizing on Michael's coffin corner accuracy.

I also was baffled by some of the kick returner decisions. I tend to lay those on the returner. The "rules of engagement" with those are pretty simple. It's hard to believe he wasn't coached on those.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT