ADVERTISEMENT

Ketch's 10 Thoughts From The Weekend: (Does Sark need to sit Ewers?_

I don't think Arch is ready completely yet though. More because of mental game than the physical side.
Out of the two QBs, I think Quinn is in his own head much more than Arch.

Was thinking about mental makeups between the two QBs on the drive in to the office this morning. The knock against Arch is that we don't know how he'll do in a Big Game environment. That it's too big a stage for a redshirt freshman no matter how physically talented. But Arch has had to deal with the pressure of media and fan expectations since he was 12. He's not your typical freshman. Combine that with the fact he's confident as hell on the field and I don't think the mental game for him is as big a hurdle as many are throwing out there.

I think he's ready. At least until Quinn gets completely healthy--which hopefully will get his head straight.
 
I'm not talking about accuracy, I'm talking about strength. Go back and watch the few throws he made past 30 yards or there about. They actually were caught because he underthrew them so badly and the receiver came back for them. You can watch his throwing motion on the deep passes, he's trying to use his arm without his core.
I don't disagree. Te why that is happening is what is open for debate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DKR-3rings
Out of the two QBs, I think Quinn is in his own head much more than Arch.

Was thinking about mental makeups between the two QBs on the drive in to the office this morning. The knock against Arch is that we don't know how he'll do in a Big Game environment. That it's too big a stage for a redshirt freshman no matter how physically talented. But Arch has had to deal with the pressure of media and fan expectations since he was 12. He's not your typical freshman. Combine that with the fact he's confident as hell on the field and I don't think the mental game for him is as big a hurdle as many are throwing out there.

I think he's ready. At least until Quinn gets completely healthy--which hopefully will get his head straight.
Good post.
 
ee0e3a40b744e2eebc3b4d949eaa9055x.jpg

Eight games into his fourth college season, the Texas football program has a Quinn Ewers problem.

Actually, the Texas football program has Quinn Ewers problems. Plural.

Coming out of a not-quite-ready-for-primetime-performance against Georgia, the single most concerning aspect of the night as it relates to Steve Sarkisian's starting quarterback is that it's kind of impossible to pin down which of the many problems is the most concerning.

Was it his shockingly poor feel and awareness for the game? Was he seeing ghosts? Why is this still happening at this stage of his career? Is he still hurt to the degree that it's a problem?

It feels a little bit like the scene from the movie Bull Durham when the team has a meeting at the mound and when the pitching coach asks what the hell is happening, Crash Davis replies, "Well, Nuke's scared because his eyelids are jammed and his old man's here. We need a live ... is it a live rooster? We need a live rooster to take the curse off Jose's glove and nobody seems to know what to get Millie or Jimmy for their wedding present. Is that about right? We're dealing with a lot of shit."



As it relates to Ewers, Texas is dealing with a lot of shit.

Consider that in the last eight days, Ewers has delivered two of his six worst statistical performances in a Texas uniform and that the performance against the Dawgs was statistically his third-worst performance of his entire college career.

462547633_919814083368179_8496552846602875306_n.png


When asked about his play after the game on Saturday night, Ewers indicated that his oblique injury is still a problem, which begs a lot of questions ... should he be playing right now? Has he been rushed back? Is whatever percentage of Ewers that exists right now better than a 100 percent Arch Manning?

Oh, and should Ewers start against Vanderbilt in six days?

Coming out of the game and a respectable second half, I felt like the answer was very probably a yes for all of the reasons that Steve Sarkisian has stressed all season. Yet, that changes if the last two games are even slightly a byproduct of Ewers being unable to play at a high level because he's physically struggling.

Maybe Ewers was making an excuse. Or maybe the excuse is the reason why he's struggling. Regardless, Texas can ill afford to go on the road next week with a quarterback that mentally believes he's not able to do what he needs to do physically to thrive at the position.

A week ago, I gave Ewers all the benefit of the doubt. I'm much less willing to do so after Saturday's performance and Ewers' explanation for his play after the game.

Ultimately, Sarkisian has to figure out the riddles and while I typically trust him to have the answers with his quarterbacks, it's hard not to wonder if his own confirmation bias in this situation is blinding him. Like Ewers throwing the ball to a receiver whether he's open or not because he's determined before the snap of the ball that he's throwing it, results be damned, it does feel like Sarkisian is making his decisions based partly on the fact that he's pre-determined that Ewers is going to start, results be damned.

Ewers is a very good college quarterback, but he hasn't been for the last two weeks.

I'm really not sure what to think about what happens next if the shaky play extends into a third week.

No. 2 - Let's be clear ...

In the event that you're wondering how you should feel about the Texas defense on a night when Georgia scored 30 points, consider the following:

* Coming into Saturday night, Carson Beck had never started a game and finished with a quarterback rating worse than the 133.9 he delivered against Vanderbilt last season. He finished the Texas game with a 77.3 rating and three turnovers.

* No Georgia wide receiver finished with more than 35 yards receiving. Arian Smith averaged 5.3 yards per reception. Dominic Lovett averaged 8.8 yards per reception. Dillon Bell averaged 9.0 yards per reception. That might be the best trio of receivers that the Texas secondary will play all season and they pitched a virtual shutout.

* The Dawgs averaged 3.6 yards per carry on the ground, while Trevor Etienne finished the night with a modest 4.8 yards per carry.

* No Georgia scoring drive went for more than 35 yards in the first half when the Dawgs built a 23-0 lead.

This unit deserved a win, but ...

c1d36843d7071047116a6890b390c4d7cee6212e.gifv


No. 3 - The Texas defense vs. the world heading into the Vandy game ...

Here's where the Texas defense ranks in the major statistical categories ...

Scoring Defense: (9.71) 1st nationally
Total Defense: (237.3): 1st nationally
Passing yards allowed: (133.0) 2nd nationally
Rushing yards Allowed: (104.3) 19th nationally
3rd down defense: (28.8%) 10th nationally
Red-Zone Percentage: (.66.7) 7th nationally
Red-Zone Scores Allowed: (8) 2nd nationally
Red-Zone Passing TDs Allowed: (0) 1st nationally
Red-Zone Rushing TDs Allowed: (4) 4th nationally
First Downs: (96) 6th nationally
Team Passing Efficiency: (88.59) 2nd nationally
Team Sacks: (2.86 per game) 18th nationally
Team Tackles For Loss: (7.6 per game) 14th nationally
Turnovers Gained: (14) 14th nationally

No. 4 - Scattershooting coming out of OU week ...

... Colin Simmons didn't make the stat sheet on Saturday night. I didn't think that was possible.

... Texas really, really needs to consider going into the Portal for a starting running back next season. None of the healthy guys truly feel like plus-options at the moment and I don't think you can count on CJ Baxter coming off of a major injury.

... The total loss of any confidence at all in Jaydon Blue as a runner (not as a receiver) is a mistake. Two games ago, he was the only player the staff wanted to give carries to and now he can't get any? That's an overcorrection that is hurting the team.

... Say what you want about whatever Arch Manning didn't do in his two series at quarterback, but his 21-yard scramble was twice as long as the next best rushing attempt by any Texas player all night.

... Sark has to start finding a way to get Ryan Wingo more touches each week.

... Very quietly, Jermayne Lole had a very good game at defensive tackle.

... Georgia dominated Texas in the kick game.

No. 5 - If I had a vote that mattered ...

1. Oregon
2. Georgia
3. Ohio State
4. Texas
5. Miami
6. Penn State
7. Tennessee
8. Clemson
9. LSU
10. Indiana

Heisman Trophy

1. Ashton Jeanty (Boise State)
2. Cam Ward (Miami)
3 Kurtis Rourke (Indiana)
4. Travis Hunter (Colorado)
5. Blake Horvath (Navy)

No. 6 - A few thoughts on Bottle-gate ...

a. Someone in the post-game show mentioned that the Texas fans acted like Tech fans in throwing crap on the field and he was spot on. That's exactly what it was ... Texas Tech fan behavior. You have to be better than that.

b. SEC officials aren't really much better than Big 12 officials. Woof.

c. Ultimately, the officials got it right, but I totally understand Kirby Smart being irate. Imagine if that call had gone against Texas.

d. Even after overturning the call, I think the Longhorns should have been hit with a 15-yard unsportsmanlike conduct penalty. I actually thought that's what was going to be announced.

e. Imagine if Wally Pryor had been around for that ...

No. 7 - Smacking the SEC around ...

Although the No. 7 Texas Volleyball team got off to the kind of slow start in the first set against Georgia that the football team could be proud of, business was handled on Sunday.

The Longhorns are alone in first place in the SEC and have lost only two sets in conference play through seven games. Next up is a rematch with the Aggies in Austin. The Aggies are one of only two teams to have taken a set from the Longhorns in the SEC.

No. 8 – BUY or SELL …

shutterstock_197241950.jpg




(Sell) Texas plays four unranked teams before it plays A&M. Come on ...



(Sell) He has the proper amount of respect. He's generally regarded as the No. 3 player at his position in the last 50 years. How much more respect does he deserve?



(Sell) Someone would take a flyer on him on day two at worst.



(Buy) Easily. It wouldn't take much to be better than mostly awful for three of four quarters with three turnovers and no real threat to throw the ball downfield.



(Buy) My reasons might be slightly different than yours, but the percentages seem about right.



(Buy) Yes, if we're talking about winning a national title.



(Sell) Texas was in this game late in the third quarter. If the defense can get a stop, the offense would have had the ball with a chance to tie the new No. 2 team in the country. Yes, there was some regression ... a lot in the first half. But, it's not the disaster you're making it out to be.



(Buy) Yup.



(Sell) I don't think this is going to happen, but I know why you are asking.



(Sell) Not in the first round.



(Buy) He's healthy in the moment and playing really well. Quinn hasn't played a really good game in more than a month. Klubnik currently has the fourth-best Heisman odds on Fan Duel. That being said, it's important to note that Klubnik hasn't gone on the road and won the games that a fully dialed-in Ewers has won.



(Buy) It's fairly obvious that when he struggles, his mechanics fall apart.



(Buy) It needed to happen in the last off-season.

No. 9 – Scattershooting all over the place …

... lulz...


... SEC Thoughts: Tennessee is an offense away from being a true national title contender. That defense is fantastic. Jalen Milroe was awful on Saturday, but still better than Ewers. Don't look now, but LSU looks very dangerous. The game in College Station should be a good one. Missouri is the worst 6-1 team in the country. Thank goodness South Carolina isn't on the Texas schedule this year. That team is dangerous on its day.

... I love it when the Cowboys have a bye week. What does that mean?

... The Texans beat the Packers on Sunday with a healthy Nico Collins. They missed him significantly ... and lost on a field goal at the buzzer.

... Bijan had his best day of the season on Sunday and the Falcons lost by 20 at home to the 4-3 Seahawks.

... Giancarlo Stanton: 16 HRs in 129 postseason at-bats. Babe Ruth: 15 HRs in 129 postseason at-bats


... Premier League Thoughts: I definitely rooted for Man United against Brentford because I don't want ten Hag fired. You could see that Man City last-minute winner coming from 5,000 miles away. Frankly, it's dispiriting. As far as red cards go, I have to applaud West Ham's Mohammed Kudus. That man earned it. Moisés Caicedo is really impressive. I wish he had signed with Liverpool. List of Premier League players with 60+ G/A vs. the Big 6 in Premier League history: Alan Shearer and Mo Salah ... that's the list.

... Bring on the MLS post-season. The regular season lasts forever.

... My current active TV viewing rankings: 1) The Penguin 2) Shrinking 3) Agatha All Along 4) The Old Man 5) Tulsa King

... We should all have inside of us what these dogs have inside of them ...


No. 10 – The List: Morgan Freeman

Earlier this week, it occurred to me that I hadn't seen the movie Lean On Me in at least a few years, which meant two things ...

a. I needed to see it asap (accomplished)
b. I needed to do a Morgan Freeman list (about to be accomplished)

Let's get on with it.

Honorable Mention: Nurse Betty

Last 5 Out: Amistad, Street Smart, Invictus, Deep Impact and High Crimes

10. Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves

I personal favorite. Don't hate.

9. Driving Miss Daisy

Feels like it has to be in the Top 10 somewhere. The only film based on an off-Broadway play to win Best Picture.

8. Million Dollar Baby

Can you believe this is his only Oscar win (in a supporting role)?

7. Gone Baby Gone

Yes, it's just a supporting role, but it's a film that has to be on the list.

6. Glory

One of my favorite Civil War movies.

5. The Dark Knight

Is this ranked too low?

4. Se7en

Am I messed up for loving this movie? If it's on, I'm watching.

3. Unforgiven

My favorite Western of all-time.

2. Lean on Me

This is the definitive Freeman performance in a starring/leading role. This might be one of the top most quoted movies in my life. I saw it when I was 13 for the first time and have probably seen it 100 times since.

"They used to call me Crazy Joe. Well now, they can call me Batman!"

"I say if you wanna kill yourself, don't **** around with it! Go on and do it expeditiously!”

"And I gave my word to God, and that's why I threw those bastards out and that's all I'm gonna say!"

"You know what he's saying right now? ‘Black bastard can't throw me out!’ You know where he's saying it? Out in the parking lot."

"Self-respect permeates every aspect of your existence"



1. The Shawshank Redemption

It's freaking Shawshank. It simply has to be No. 1.
Ketch, I didn't imagine the Morgan Freeman list would be my favorite part of 10 Thoughts right after the Georgia game but here we are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ketchum
Totally agree.
BTW,
I think you said on your podcast that some of your sources inside the program say that the injury is still a problem--and Sark said it is not at his press conference. This inconsistency is a little weird. Although, I'm ok with giving Sark the benefit of the doubt, I tend to believe your sources on this--particularly since he obviously hasn't been the same since he got injured. And Sark also is a little contradictory when it comes to injuries IMO. This is one thing that bothers me some about Sark--I know it's a coach speak thing to maintain a certain message, but this isn't the first time he's been cagy with injuries and it adds to overall confusion and players getting hammered unfairly--if in fact they are. It makes a difference.

Anything more about this?
 
  • Like
Reactions: suzerain79
Ketch, I didn't imagine the Morgan Freeman list would be my favorite part of 10 Thoughts right after the Georgia game but here we are.
I'm not sure how to take that. lol.
 
BTW,
I think you said on your podcast that some of your sources inside the program say that the injury is still a problem--and Sark said it is not at his press conference. This inconsistency is a little weird. Although, I'm ok with giving Sark the benefit of the doubt, I tend to believe your sources on this--particularly since he obviously hasn't been the same since he got injured. And Sark also is a little contradictory when it comes to injuries IMO. This is one thing that bothers me some about Sark--I know it's a coach speak thing to maintain a certain message, but this isn't the first time he's been cagy with injuries and it adds to overall confusion and players getting hammered unfairly--if in fact they are. It makes a difference.

Anything more about this?
a. The injury talk never came up last week, but did after this game. I am a bit of a skeptical hippo.

b. Sark isn't always straight-forward with injuries and so we have to remember that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: aarontxex
Sounds like Chastok knows what he's talking about.

This remains the funniest comment from yesterday, especially since the poster he is referring to has not responded to my very lengthy response from... 20 hours ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: UTDB
a. The injury talk never came up last week, but did after this game. I am a bit of a skeptical hippo.

b. Sark isn't always straight-forward with injuries and so we have to remember that.
That's for sure--he isn't--and it isn't doing his players any favors either.
Quinn isn't the first player that has been discussed where Sark has been somewhat deceptive (for lack of a better term).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Touchstone
Oh trust me, I'm not arguing for playing Quinn or sitting him. I honestly don't know what the best thing is. I don't think Arch is ready completely yet though. More because of mental game than the physical side. I'm just trusting that Sark is doing the right thing for the team, for Quinn, for the program. I'm just telling you what I think is happening, it's just my opinion. I do think people need to stop dogging on Quinn though, I think he's doing what he can to still try and help the team.
Good point-and I agree.
I hope Sark is doing the right thing, but I'm not sure--particularly if Quinn is still hurt and he's not being truthful about it. That doesn't help the team. It creates much more confusion and criticism that it can possibly help. Just my opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shrevehorn
He doesn't think that's what he's doing. He believes in Ewers. He just needs that faith to be rewarded.
Agree, but he has a record of playing players who were injured. He played Casey when he had a broken throwing hand, X when he could not catch because of a broken hand. It is obvious that Quinn cannot throw the ball as he does when healthy. He needs to sit until he can aggressively throw the ball downfield where there have been many open receivers. Then he needs to be back in the lineup. We need a healthy three year starter for our stretch run.
 
Last edited:
From memory only 2 deep balls from Quinn during the game, one to Wingo where we got a PI because the ball was under thrown, and another to Golden that was caught but way under thrown and Golden made a great play.
This is what I like about these two guys--Golden in particularly--he probably knows something is wrong with Quinn and he's doing his best to help him out by making a catch under less than ideal circumstances--that makes him a great receiver IMO.
Wingo is going to be special IMO.
Love to see great receivers trying to help their quarterback out--and it makes a difference to quarterbacks, particularly when they are struggling.
 
.. The total loss of any confidence at all in Jaydon Blue as a runner (not as a receiver) is a mistake. Two games ago, he was the only player the staff wanted to give carries to and now he can't get any? That's an overcorrection that is hurting the team.

===================================================================


Is this Sark, or Choice?
Yeah,
and I'm not sure why Gibson isn't getting more work--it can't all be because of pass protection. Who knows? He may have been useful running between the tackles in last week's game, to back Ga's defense off--but the never used him at all.
For the most part, I think he's been productive when he's played.
 
That's for sure--he isn't--and it isn't doing his players any favors either.
Quinn isn't the first player that has been discussed where Sark has been somewhat deceptive (for lack of a better term).

I think that's just part of him. We're learning that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Touchstone
Agree, but he has a record of playing players who were injured. He played Casey when he had a broken throwing hand, X when he could not catch because of a broken hand. It is obvious that Quinn cannot throw the ball as he does when healthy. He needs to sit until he can aggressively throw the ball downfield where there have been many open receivers. Then he needs to be back in the lineup. We need a healthy three starter for our stretch run.
+1
 
a. Sark says he's not.
b. This leadership and control is becoming a myth. They need him to play well more than anything else.
I don’t think Sark said that he wasn’t playing hurt. He said he didn’t know if he was playing hurt. A litte white lie. Then he added that everyone is playing somewhat hurt.

I think Ewers got reinjured on the sack but didn’t tell anyone. He was clearly unable to step into his throws and was afraid of getting hurt further.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Topcat79
I don’t think Sark said that he wasn’t playing hurt. He said he didn’t know if he was playing hurt. A litte white lie. Then he added that everyone is playing somewhat hurt.

I think Ewers got reinsured on the sack but didn’t tell anyone. He was clearly unable to step into his throws and was afraid of getting hurt further.
This.
Ewers is either hurt or is regressing ……..
Either way - Arch needs to be taking snaps.
 
2. Lean on Me

This is the definitive Freeman performance in a starring/leading role. This might be one of the top most quoted movies in my life. I saw it when I was 13 for the first time and have probably seen it 100 times since.

"They used to call me Crazy Joe. Well now, they can call me Batman!"

"I say if you wanna kill yourself, don't **** around with it! Go on and do it expeditiously!”

"And I gave my word to God, and that's why I threw those bastards out and that's all I'm gonna say!"

"You know what he's saying right now? ‘Black bastard can't throw me out!’ You know where he's saying it? Out in the parking lot."
Oh I don't think I could put Lean On Me that high consider how strong Freeman's resume: Glory, Se7en, those are so good. But I do agree 100% that Lean On Me is super quotable.

Here is a pretty funny review of it (even if a little harsh):

 
The biggest problems with ewers last Sat night was not his passes being off due to his recovery from his injury. The problems were his pocket awareness and non-movement in the pocket; footwork; and throwing a horrific INT (just assuming that the inside receiver would be open and that the CB covering the outside WR would run with that WR down the field) at our 30 that only inexperienced QBs can be excused from throwing. Nothing to do with him not getting enough on the ball due to his recovery. He has regressed big time after the Mich game and I'm not sure if we will consistently see his "elite" passing games again. I hope Sark is ready to pull ewers and put Arch in for a good amount of time or for good when ewers struggles again and the game is still truly winnable. Don't wait until we get down by more than 2 scores.
 
Last edited:
The biggest problems with ewers last Sat night was not his passes being off due to his recovery from his injury. The problems were his pocket awareness and non-movement in the pocket; footwork; and throwing a horrific INT at our 30 that only inexperienced QBs can be excused from throwing. Nothing to do with him not getting enough on the ball due to his recovery. He has regressed big time after the Mich game and I'm not sure if we will consistently see his "elite" passing games again. I hope Sark is ready to pull ewers and put Arch in for a good amount of time or for good when ewers struggles again and the game is still truly winnable. Don't wait until we get down by more than 2 scores.
It is clear that Quinn is not able to throw the ball downfield or with zip. He is still injured and needs to sit until he recovers. Fully.
 
  • Like
Reactions: boernefan
It is clear that Quinn is not able to throw the ball downfield or with zip. He is still injured and needs to sit until he recovers. Fully.
Maybe and maybe not about the injury. He threw fine on the 20-30 yard cross incompletion pass to Wingo in the 2nd half. Needed to throw a lob instead of a line drive. He's not a good 30 yard plus passer anyway. Like I said, he stunk against a good/fierce pass rush and all the NFL scouts saw it. He can redeem himself by playing a lot better (which we have seen before but never against a fierce pass rush) in the remaining games or Arch will replace him or we may not qualify for or go far in the playoffs.
 
Oh I don't think I could put Lean On Me that high consider how strong Freeman's resume: Glory, Se7en, those are so good. But I do agree 100% that Lean On Me is super quotable.

Here is a pretty funny review of it (even if a little harsh):


a, I laughed.
b. I will stand on the table for this movie.
 
My initial disillusionment was when Dallas was not large enough to contain the egos of Jerry and Jimmy, Jimmy being the best judge of talent I have ever seen. Then I gritted my teeth through the succession of stooges as head coach.

Then came Bill Parcells. First of all Bill’s play calling was schizophrenic. In one game he was a riverboat gambler, taking long chances, and in the next game he was punting from the opponent’s 34 yard line. My final disillusionment came during Bill’s infatuation with the aging Vinnie Testaverde. It was the year that Dallas was clearly out of the playoffs by midway through the season and had two young and (I thought) promising quarterbacks on the roster that, in the long range interests of the team, needed to be given an opportunity to play. Bill firmly announced that he was sticking with 42 year old Testaverde for the remainder of the year. I concluded that I had better uses for my time than to focus my attention on such an ineptly managed franchise.

I never looked back and it has been 25 years since Dallas was relevant in the league.









P
 
I'm just saying he's playing hurt, and they need he's leadership and control of the offense. As good as Arch is going to be next year, he's not ready yet. The game needs to slow down and they can't give him the full offense yet. This is of course JMO. They aren't going to put that out there that he's hurt more as I'm sure Teams will try and take advantage more and etc. I just can tell by watching QE that he is not healthy yet. They aren't even throwing the ball downfield much at all these last 2 games.
100% but lots not blame anyone else other than the QB.
 
This remains the funniest comment from yesterday, especially since the poster he is referring to has not responded to my very lengthy response from... 20 hours ago.
I know you aren't referring to me? I did respond to your response my friend.
 
78 didn't lose any money. I've had 2 NFL scouts convey that to me in the last 48 hours.

I don't have it in me to fight the good fight on the rest. We agree on pretty much nothing. I'm not going to be able to convince you.

I appreciate the discussion, though. Have a good night.
Correct. We are going to agree to disagree. Admit that you have always had a crooked eye when it comes to QE. Not sure why but you have. At the end of the day QE needs to play better for this to turn out like we want it to. Having said that, the Oline has to play better and Sark has to figure out how to get more from the running game period. The running game helps control the game and keeps the defense honest.
 
Leadership and control mean nothing if Quinn can’t execute the gameplan.
It does if the alternative can't execute the game plan either based on how the supporting cast is playing.
 
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT