I'l say it again, when he was healthy Thompson had a 187 rating and posted the greatest quarterback performance in the history of the OU rivalry.
Only confirmation bias would tell you at this point that a freshman who hasn't played a game since his junior year in high school is on the level of a fourth-year player posting numbers no other quarterback in the history of the program has ever posted (albeit a small sample size).
You keep saying "when he was healthy", which games are you counting exactly? From Rice to OU? So we're talking about Rice, Tech, TCU, and OU, correct? Two of those schools, any QB in a Sark offense we will light up. Or do you disagree that Ewers isn't good enough to dice up Rice and Tech from last year?
Now we're talking about TCU and OU. TCU Casey barely passed for 50%, with 140 yards. And he played amazing vs OU, nobody is taking that away. But if this is the 4 game sample you're talking about, this wasn't some stretch that was impossible to be replicated by the top QB prospect ever against some of the worst defenses in the country.
Last year Tech, TCU, and Rice were all outside of the top 100 in defense. So if you're gonna just give off ratings, and focus on a small sample size that ironically focuses on the worst defenses we faced all year, let's use some context is all. What you are saying is Ewers is incapable of playing that well, vs bad defenses, and I disagree. We literally just saw a WR come in after not playing a game since his junior year, and post historical numbers. But now another elite prospect we're gonna put a ceiling on him and treat him like any other QB prospect?